this prompted a question in my mind just now, and an answer came

how is it that static cryptographic identities seem to be strong in nostr

partly, because if someone were to actually post events with the key they managed to steal from you

you'd see it the next moment you open your nostr client and it displays the event kind they posted with that key

right now kind 1's are definitely a no-go for an nsec thief

because many clients are retarded about DMs though, and auth, they might exploit their achievement by riding your reputation with their stolen booty

but at the same time, the conventions in the protocol are so leaky, that it's possible they would be detected by someone who would mention you in a kind 1 that you seem to be sending spam

this is an interesting thing, and may well be why nostr's DAU is slow to grow

most people think it's insecure, on the face of it

those who use it, never have a problem because it's so easy to get noticed doing bad thing

most of the relays don't actually keep logs and nobody really talks about that possibility, but it exists, and the bad guys might well consider it best to only use your nsec to read your encrypted events, and not alert you they have it by posting

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzpqz78jvtg23pwksgzentfcrhh2ejzdh2dn6tn9m2j5jknytancefqqsdlq4s60cxuj7uevlnw62cf7squ2ecvtlh6thygczwffhgxm5tahqdnnarj

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

That does seem like an ideal use case for a stolen nsec.

The only reason why I asked is because you are a prolific commenter on nostr, it is impressive how you have 18k relatively thoughtful comments on people’s stuff. And typically the comments are minutes after the original post.

Just wanted to check to see if you turned your mind into an AI and tasked it with responding to everyone.

i have good memory, and i try to gather information that is relevant to me and people who i like, and share it with them

and yes i spend way too much time with this thing open lol... i need a woman who will deny me to go in unto her if i have been to chatty