‘Could a machine ever be said to have made its own decisions? Could a machine have beliefs? Could a machine make mistakes? Could a machine believe it made its own decisions? Could a machine erroneously attribute free will to itself? Could a machine come up with ideas that had not been programmed into it in advance? Could creativity emerge from a set of fixed rules? Are we - even the most creative among us - but passive slaves to the laws of physics that govern our neurons?’

From the foreword by Douglas Hofstadter for ‘The Enigma’ by Andrew Hodges

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Am I the same if you copied me molecule by molecule?

I love this question ❤️‍🔥 I think no 🫂 unless clone Dan was to have the exact same life as you, but that’s impossible. He’d have his own way of thinking and feeling. Would be so interesting. Like the ‘be right back’ black mirror episode

Every cell in your body will be dead, consumed and replaced in 7 years time (assuming you survive that long, and consider your life to be the same one as all your prior moments)

Plants might also have a subjective consciousness some are stipulating.

Don’t tell the vegans 👀 we’ll never hear the end of it

All jokes aside, that’s beautiful ❤️‍🔥

Currently kinda.

The problem being that defining consciousness has been a challenge for over 2000 years. Fundamentally we are chemical computers. If we transfered a human mind to a computer does that computer have a mind, or is it a copy, or approximation of a mind?

If you press a button on a hydrolic press, the computer controls that action. Did the computer make a choice?

Is a person not simply following their programming based on all past experience and instinct?

This is a hard question to answer. One that will likely not be answered in our lifetime.

They are very upset! 😂