Nostr Web Client

No. Kind 10002 is only public outbox/write relays and public inbox (that is for things like replies and reactions to public posts).

I would not want someone sending a DM to my wot.brightbolt.net, for instance, or relay.brightbolt.net/inbox. Rather, I only want DMs to be sent to inbox.nostr.wine and relay.brightbolt.net/chat, hence why they are a separate list.

10002, as far as I know, has no means of differentiating between which relays are public inboxes and which are a DM inboxes.

Djuri 8mo ago

Yes, thats what I meant.

How I see it:

10002 is your generic "I want to connect to all these relays" list for the clients you use.

10050 is your "please deliver here and nowhere else" list for giftwrapped DMs.

But I do expect that you always want to connect to your Inbox relays, so they are in the kind 10002 list as well...

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Dikaios1517 8mo ago

No. I don't always want to connect to my DM inbox relays. I ONLY want to connect to them for DMs. That is why they aren't in my 10002. I don't want people sending replies to my kind 1 notes to my DM inbox relays. That's not what they are for.

Djuri 8mo ago

Good point, I it wrong in my head that it was a list for apps but the NIPs are indeed very clear about that its used to inform where the users publish. Will change this in n17.chat!

Dikaios1517 8mo ago

Great news! Looking forward to trying it out!