Replying to Avatar unclebobmartin

#[1] I don't know of you are the right one to send this to.

It looks to me as though eden.nostr.land can get stuck in a loop resending events over and over.

Here's the flow of events that I coaxed out of it:

First of all notice that the "since" and "until" times are the same. That's not a factor, I've tried it with different times.

Second notice that there are two events that match the since/until criteria and they repeat over and over. What you can't see from this listing is that there is about 30 seconds between each batch. In some of my experiements I saw the EOSE, but in others it did not appear.

["REQ","ms-past",{"since":1677844901,"until":1677844901,"authors":["08f3b589f6","387519cafd","8a44facb32","3946adbb2f","d0e5724689","dcecb5c4c2","47f7163bed","dfa14803f5","388a27f5a9","f9d0e566db","c32227801e","e8541da6f0","588e5ea209","5c30f128ab","87816efbed","4ca4f5533e","74ffc51cc3","b7c66ce6f7","a3c60e070c","6e3cc30c68","5956f7ddb4","2444d2460f","4ac4324b32","cf7ad05f8e","144425ff32","343558f07b","875705d034","184e489982","c6ce4c595d","68658c462f","8766a54ef9","f5424d002f","16b8676587","a8abe37636","be1d89794b","470be0e814","356e99a0f7","0882b33293","d7e747f60a","16b2a2edab","4159b16e6c","0000000082","6c55a582d2","6fd3915a55","79b647ba67","0abb589750","fee3f1fe01","4228367564","823bfe17ca","0e021bbf8e","ecceb083ea","19e358b801","6b8f57e047","9c8e6bcf84","5a8e581f16","048ec58aba","772bd267df","d6f2f8baca","fd4169cc72","7bc0ff3de7","6652d2ef6b","506c61ea9b","8f6945b472","25bf0c3824","9b3e1c9de7","724acb5013","3efdaebb1d","0327e687d6","310b39e642","3c9fb25848","b238e13609","23708a76e7","bb65a10ef0","8c5ec8b339","157422841b","2d11d3a312","033502184c","2719dfdd5c","ff24202025","5192759b0e","1068b93ad4","19e6783d3e","2f242e12cd","ad46db12ee","0444f37b7a","5500a99f7a","99ad81211b","0d6c8388dc","74772a29e9","ae3909314f","47f33c191e","5b20c6a456","f93b1ee46e","8582d172e1","be07921849","3cc926bad8","b310ed0a54","c427296499","100e0bfacb","be57e811c1","af1ae057cb","b4e7b919b4","d2d4028904","1bd191b93f","1a299f502a","4ac24d2ee8","0b68912f15","d67d1b497a","0f073599d9","ed88dc177d","11d7098d61","c5aec31e83","5c0775b1ae","27f211f454","392daba0ea","b1dd5e8ed1","a80455732d","f57d8cf57b","287187d0da","0095c837e8","f58649dc9b","9ed60990ea","84e09b451f","b2d670de53","a72f525f9f","b1576eb99a","2f7463a476","c1fe52f8f5","adfe275604","b2dd40097e","c48e29f04b","42320b6327","8aec99ba38","d77ded7775","e64b77a577","339db62c91","bda8cab190","1f5cd0b761","1641df9606","c073baa319","00000001fc","5a9c48c8f4","dc062cf626","66a2eec5ef","afe56dc7cd","9dea278559","6aaed493c0","b999bf535f","e723752a74","d659eda2d6","b234d771b2","aa55a479ad","b82b98dad6","b10c00dff1","de8ef91036","4dfae6fd5b","62fe024163","5a25a05013","ee42e08ee1","f677f7b357","f2e2506a23","d3e3d17abc","7abafef00c","88dd3d4924","a4ec6308a9","4690087445","7395a732d8","18f7a1e0a6","667c9841cb","0f65aa4d25","69a0a0910b","f046f9ba4e","76c59c723c","566516663d","bff98bcb77","22a0bf0c34","ce69afb446","95294fe918","db820bf9a5","f26606e331","a832fb98b0","772383c8d5","b9e45e9844","4fb82036ff","f7380c11f6","93b516bc96","297bc16357","2cde0e02bd","29f63b70d8","bd8aed58fe","4ccef69e9e","691df800a8","274760e2f7","ea9f88c5bd","fec1f0c9fa","cba52eae58","3b6cd618a0","738ea36ef7","87b77f6676","9c09586414","046c436b2a","1d70a5069c","74dcec31fd","090254801a","df15c3282b","1f679d7da5","a91e8ec24b","0695cb75db","974d0f476f","b19d5ba0da","dc6e531596","db33363379","461cded2ae","d8c954472f","f94684333e","664e070fe2","9cfdabfe01","be7955fece","9609b09345","169916bf39","43b881abb0","378e7b1b3a","1e9d809ea9","b2722dd1e1","ddff07845a","cfe0a23ae2","02abcb3c6e","1870bad2b8","c765522880","154842f29b","ff2d033286","87dd086247","5dfd2ac9e6","fe2cef4087","5b625cc6da","65be27514e","296acbbca1","42f92ac202","d36b034e41","05ac8fc068","d5abca3791","0c24e32352","19fefd7f39","473e67022c","86add3aba3","3f8e32d654","6587f9aa6a","b28a0714f8","b9c194f68c","a9786646d7","8c3b267e9d","ae8111c3a6","0d94b0e571","1aacfc2b8b","8158c3897d","f56dee7e27","8c128f0c05","10266a3633","c3d1eddcf8","ffece32b6c","d76726da1b","a2e5c53fb1","0000000032","c25ed1c260","11b9a89404","f36a9469c6","3e6d6eea71","9682c33f90","f2ff7ad4f0","495fab2968","ddf03aca85","c2c20ec0a5","b19b99c15f","ac4e18391f","307981b227","df79a1e1c4","c04b09e362","3242fcf0fa","0a31839d2f","d5fc505d5c","85080d3bad","5ae0f99d27","cf6f9a7691","7ec387e781","89223314d2","813cf5bbaf","99f0edec92","2123cc7887","b8c010b5b0","07eced8b63","0a0f1bee94","eb3a338922","9f75525a0d","675b84fe75","3bc8802de4","0000000ec7","36435f2d84","d12feb34b3","7abbf30675","51fc720920","67caf9fdb0","eb362a4ad5","7e88f589d2","f67de9f8b9","23d4939461","1dc754f192","bae7787494","0000000033","fd3fdb0d0d","e214188b0f","dee3ff75c4","bb18989059","0ae918a0fd","a78f617aaa","43e3ca00a9","563a5b3283","32b2a87b90","25c6fe9968","4f68ba146d","c05f902fb6","3135937d11","54c646255f","457e17b7ea","afa73d6e1d","05fecd5f87","f2c96c97f6","e602090869","baa529237d","b10c000007","77e7533ff0","241fb407a1","d99ee07829","5b0e8da6fd","7fca152887","af70b1b1c0","477ef2459c","408f7150e4","ac9ec02017","9092c8735b","776bc89bf7","0adf67475c","ce5061bfcc","105dfb7467","40b7299f5a","e4c822745a","2c1882ea65","c57717ec7a","c40ac0ff94","ca5ab93419","2c7ebfed8d","28ca019b78","c3022a79d7","d82272f522","e3f0c72e7b","599c3f5060","35f94835ca","5b0183ab6c","82f2cccd27","8b1348871a","4e90698164","1351d2d57c","688eebf6b6","a3eb29554b","e88a691e98","e2f28c1ac6","a12535e8bf","bef724f6f1","98c9e628a9","618b7bcd1e","957e3c20a7","b365069ada","5534355104","f88d6b13f7","ee85604f8e","3d37d966d5","6849675eb1","b7ed68b062","50f20d1b43","c95c4591bb","44313b79df","5ea41f16a2","3060084c00","2391212417","2197dbe0f0","d97cd1bcc2","a0d32fe278","e06b11a198","50054d07e2","6d23993803","5a36b20ed0","6106650461","f8bb809cec","f48c9e44c2","1f254ae909","dd663577f4","fb649213b8","7a78fbfec6","6ac74cdff1","925ed95833","1318c3a77e","ab6e4c12e1","ee32690bd9","5e51341318","2b5c634536","1306edd66f","c1fc7771f5","2779f3d9f4","9d1222b04c","81c5aaf335","882bc3c478","21763c7179","44dc1c2db9","e751877e74","383888cf3d","36528a71d8","4b12f6132a","a2ee3c86c2","72c29c440a","709bd2be88","234d39919c","cf17b2f713","318c6318cf","47f20ae624","eef1b169dd","5575794dd0","5b12cc0c99","32e1827635","63bfd10375","72b1eca228","1bbb832457","6389be6491","4872ee10c5","4ee87869fd","9ec7a77816","7a0c7b0989","bd31b09ec4","f4a466ce15","cf9847798b","f1fdb0c14b","2ee39cb14e","6f09e65546","611f77b209","4eb88310d6","f36f2eb961","d4124ba7b7","22a12a14b0","605bf34307","fef6bc34aa","e5c530616c","59c638d40f","d149cab746","a60e79e0ed","84a8a5de95","bf353c70f3","40dbb0e337","c060b31fe2","3762d3159b","05bf1db47a","8366f5f257","4c8b3528e5","e920acd0ab","8dec0c55eb","a367f9eb1c","6c82941087","04dfa12219","168e54bba0","961c0d5b5e","ad4ffbc3df","6a3a60099f","8f44c56131","27da3f032e","edfa27d49d","47bae3a008","561f62e2a6","b07d216f2f","3129509e23","f8e6c64342","99abbeb54d","3d2e515086","b3b1d58093","36e65b503e","25a2192dcf","bc385dfbea","c1e7280625","c73e75dba8","5b54d5c6b7","72894dc8a1","240391a9ec","4491ed732a","9dad9c2ef6","59d78ead1f","70798862ec","99332e0cd1","4ffc11bfa2","ea09f3038a","780ab38a84","38b07a31f3","594cdd723f","305890e98f","2edbcea694","ec99edc556","eaf41f497c","686a09bd40","e8c7df1dfe","e8ed3798c6","a1eac11b67","1cbccdbd3b","4ce01692f1","62bbe73992","0c3e82accc","0810b5bc4c","9f37f2e3f6","39ad819396","7cd9fa1518","2ca5096201","f071dc246b","39633fcea3","8d0d521dde","8f4a118e52","63b89dde9e","9093d3b976","eb6ed93ee1","be7a5291b5","991968d48e","5b29255d5e","e0a3fb3a3e","00000e48d2","f8286180e1","3b8bd779b4","2ef93f01cd","640268b633","9d065f84c0","2c33d143bc","93ed4e5365","dc9d9a15f2","0797a6e2e4","960c4ed4a2","6511545afd","d67e8131f9","199a8ef55a","abbb2bb6c2","e6a92d8b6c","e1a2a84853","5dd4da7701","42a0523b65","6d334336f9","34af16f178","59039fe610","bc6403e08c","6c535d95a8","724c2b87b6","56f1e8450d","8a9cf82355","7d9e21ce1c","7035ef20f5","84fe3febc7","a9f8b3f2ac","b7b1382ea9","4b0572ab1f","d411848a42","0f36d20bc0","e3e3472d32","031ea30618","8f6635c1c5","7fa56f5d69","65ed60f499","f52edbe413","3f751c3eeb","496643ecae","e60d3e88ba","ce2ea87b75","62fdd90f4a","b5aee0ae32","ab46015f08","1fccce68f9","5c3d8f0d8d","77b504e58f","ca1a73104d","20ece5ce39","351810286d","b0a7265070","27610c8cfd","9b50cbb6f0","feee2f9110","c73c169b24","64796b541e","a3c52e1ccd","783d3d0a4c","3f152ab665","7911c88a4a","c79941e29f","e37a955032","305a4615d3","a903b72b95","2bda4f0344","4899778146","939fb33e2d","05e90eff47","cb06b83c11","d1e60465c2","7e7a69eb53","417e77a251","5be6446aa8","fd02664857","8098608c9b","1f86acc87d","f61abb9886","1538f44cd9","460c25e682","4b46c41d47","7f5c2b4e48","8dc650dedc","7bdef7be22","7215b2db87","7b7224a600","815d179fdf","7a7a6e8015","5971fe3787","0da54ff10e","80763febea","6e33981c6c","1ad34e8aa2","431d8112be","1c9d368fc2","c161a5ba8d","c7063ccd7e","17b209d34f","bc52210b20","dfdb7b101c","d684e2cfc2","a5e0721598","3878d95db7","95405f1621","690183f064","c44ab6eeeb","b44b019384","5144fe88ff","16e0365db0","5c508c34f5","0000007039","49e2566f8b","0114bb11dd","8f9efe5e5b","43dedbafef","dedf91f5c5","e005ba6cc0","887645fef0","6846296c01","e76450df94","fa90c095c6","3e549502be","871bbcafed","b75b5e8dea","2af01e0d6b","fd9023eb93","5133a0947a","7414b2d02d","eecd7dfbb7","d99211aeeb","d49a9023a2","ee6ea13ab9","c43bbb58e2","548ce7c9f4","acedd35970","02f925b38c","efc83f01c8","a20a47a865","2c645e1b96","1e4c4fafe7","d99b507177","199ff2c585","aee35e75ec","c76d159ddd","b629f7cd24","13d25add6b","b8791b050a","16fa0fe9d1","46b2f1d93f","68680737c7","840c6faabe","112f54c7a7","9fa5cd6c8e","15af9e028d","27154fb873","2ae911b71d","27c4d775be","d3f95267cc","c8df6ae886","3235036bd0","0576eee7f5","e546a9c961","aed0fcaa99","25926eda8d","0ece92ada4","f3a408b554","cdb55b719d","11e979b27c","cbd3b7e12f","6435490d16","04d364fe55","d220c7513b","01d76603bc","649eefe468","58dece9ff6","4e8a6e5ea0","e0cdd0395d","d7eec3f46e","18905d0a5d","b2b9a5f476","e6ce615432","4f6728209e","b88c7f007b","094ed88c96","52f6c80b23","14cb67dcb9","1d65518e85","09e935f7c0","e89538241b","106963c854","492bf025bc","aea4ad900a","15e3a72e35","b7bfe58d10","70eb44f4e3","e72a30387a","eed5de31c0","151b02c7ec","c26b4e8163","148d1366a5","d8a2bcbb99","22a9c3ae91","29a96708b9","0840fa9537","8484107b4d","50d46fb072","081f3b0c10","f25c7d6585","53afcab521","ec79b568bd","3f5ce0bcfa","370596fdc1","5e51094ff2","b65a341890","b1d03fdeb0","b488387c61","1bc70a0148","6e6280bcf5","ee0e01eb17","f396429324","ab7e23dbf5","c6ee20a53f","0bbcab6bfc","21a8dee768","9303ab260a","55c0752df4","2e9397a8c9","3ed3579663","b22fef18cb","5cad82c898","75489bb3f9","8fc2d2c705","c5072866b4","f5c815e68e","62303da232","7f5237e9f7","fc3f6665b1","e7424ad457","f1ebc3df0e","756098de19","e0f59d8904","07cfbf55b2","e5177ebf51","3326da0cf7","46fcbe3065","9ed5b4c723","9bfa0d33a9","b481d853bd","85c22eb535","8fe3f243e9","e83db19618","85e6f91b06","6ef322e8d9","cedab81be4","46b3f0634b","6235faf91a","40b9c85fff","e26e17b4e0","ba18221291","3a0392022a","db8db62d26","a180855847","c2622c916d","1846fbe891","5eff2d5db2","8944d603bc","0dcfcaac3d","78874d3b60","607f56cd27","ff04a0e6cd","f4100be472","93048b0f32","472f440f29","66d06550f3","c1a8cf318c","2244ad1eac","697e4e6967","00bbf046e3","8f87ac34eb","9348d77597","06b7819d7f","904ea00a4a","2675df6e55","4df7b43b3a","5676b7cb21","e37d948a0e","2af8d53040","692f3821c0","33061e8c0d","5a939a30b7","74f04b4ee1","cf1fe4d458","cb5146cb68","c99dc5c133","eaf1a13a03","84a7487c34","045745ac0e","44dcb4b6a3","11674b2d32","9839a36d51","25de661e94","865c92a207","5a6440553a","bcea2b9850","dd5e0ac3b0","020f2d21ae","e4f695f05b","fcf70a45cf","9c9ecd7c8a","faa9e6eacc","89bfe407c6","58dd23538a","20d88bae0c","84de08882b","62f6c5ff12","e83b66a8ed","4fecd36ea2","8a4eeea08a","8312f96c33","782b3ed551","285d4ca25c","73c7ff2146","1a8bb46f3a","facf399fbd","3ddeea5270","36ae0a7f4b","bc8f5f0bc5","50c5957a16","ee11a5dff4","02abc40b7b","c7c8f645fd","3f2a859b68","bf8eb2aa25","b83a28b7e4","1bf21c2e8f","0000005cc4","9c6a05cae8","0e2bdefdde","3fd69ce5a6","d777d51ddf","8bad4693e0","97f9497f76","ed1814df1a","b39593bf6e","e417ee3d91","76f319d4b4","e1ed06b418","f7a8be339d","bb094a2a75","ac20203ec8","f35288ac93","35b23cd02d","489485b5d4","f0f44f7d6e","36eb52922f","a4cb51f461","fe2d5cf62e","9f376635bf","03b5036dc3","7e2ffb634a","0ea2dab336","149bc0d45e","d4b0588404","4dcc6ecb93","2b15989902","0c05eccb05","7c765d407d","6b3b63acd5","2bb7be52b0","a5e93aef8e","9a2dda390f","cf9413eb6b","c705a5941f","bb0b14408c","72ac4edde5","c271eb8a39","aa3315d2f3","aed01006bb","e742771a12","2183e94758","f614154bef","03ed4fd095","8ec86ac9e1","1e78f481f7","368f4e0027","e75692ec71","04b359506f","9fcdf610e7","5ed4fa9d1d","5748fbe6ec","54d15e2932","41db8c8559","3c1ba7d42c","c1e9ab3a56","3b3a42d34c","67eb726f7b","e8795f9f48","06b0d07a0c","f0bed2e112","33868b6613","d2a90855cc","330454558e","8e9116fa76","7ed19e6e8f","91b2013489","846307688a","0000000003","c5cfda98d0","463adf0942","a249234ba0","e05593eb83","c80b5248fb","dc4dc25a23","fd3423d0cc","dfabd531f9","72936ba9f4","fc971a0786","7e83db6263","e1055729d5","28012e707c","f514ef7d18","26bd32c672","644aa0bf6f","472c8918ab","f5bda68c3d","9846c592b0","97c70a4436","81db8ce143","af551accea","d8bcfacfcd","3bf0c63fcb","9b4f6c8ce3","5761b39ac2","4f775440d6","8eee8f5a00","8bfe298430","3335d373e6","0fecf65daa","000000001f","b8a50c8015","7db3155c36","9936a53def","6f0ec447e0","fb25f7b945","4a8c13dd19","62ea16ed61","1b0181c349","227e0bcb11","f7dbfb13ee","d8a2c33f2e","2f3ad1357d","e5058191b3","13b5f0afeb","967ffcc98f","f58fcf6356","5a462fa604","0cd2acf75d","ed80013845","ed3090dd7e","c1e7fc21b4","a0f69816b6","607e732b12","161d06909c","c238c7f799","a2d9f79646","021df4103e","0b118e40d6","ca4ef0d885","85b580e3ee","2c614f67d5"]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"a864e19e925bce1ed8f1ef0cde918e55182f6b1e93ac37a8c09b3cdf60d6e6e4","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"5651c0b9fc6bb0950534f67db8f16c58958966833d0eb315b962684f22b622966d858303e454a495f01a0723c6d5fee639a4aaddbecdbefd2d32872e775523e7","tags":[["p","2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc"],["bolt11","lnbc220n1pjqrcvmpp5uf5svph5snesx5jrchjjevxum023t3wfk3fnvyevfkvfvwsh07lshp5zlz2mflru26grw6jy9450eavtrqd95egs8a2jxa6kmqfwgkhxlcscqzpgxqzfvsp59jgkqte57rzj34wdea7g502eufv56yt4wy3ftddtm6gcalvz8vxq9qyyssq43jfpsryh6ryua0gnekghm0j4le7706c6tprry86q82zpnzcx66qe6nhrdg22j4dqmwm5h7gd38lwqfrjkcjxujx4ur327nvj8v2kusq2jpzxx"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844890,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"grimyend76\"],[\"amount\",\"22000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[2].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"47234ce73a5a2563dce90507bc9ac237d02c9adf3699f784ce1fb6f2e608335a\",\"sig\":\"e788057275671a404b67fb1dece2673bda01915727ed960de11f77865a9e3d78e18f590119ef0296401ff7f35053ffad67f37583aedf28641e8037d26a1e3d06\"}"],["preimage","e2690606f484f3035243c5e52cb0dcdbd515c5c9b45336132c4d98963a177fbf"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"8ecc76eff7ff9d52d54d111698624ff1afd2db04645c41253596fcd12bbd696e","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"f1c2b9317f58509a2d5031676a4bddf3f07747af33b834e22c285ce7da870a9b4bc4c564679212ce668745e73da8fc18236fcb939b27d1ae81efbf8e937f6367","tags":[["p","ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7"],["bolt11","lnbc320n1pjqrcvepp56fakne87ah9cgpcsfkqe943uzxw0mdvstc5exl6rhcnef3jrkdkqhp56gydzwmjx76tu9qkz4e8cda6rytslmcwkfgqzz9acuz9kdqux7uqcqzpgxqzfvsp56cqkq9vtnk329qjele4fd3g9d3cvfhqqdx3p0s0t4tx9lcyr39tq9qyyssq4fhedpy4m0jqg3pgj0q0cksqfql5d99r6ag4t85pn2e2t5kv9xmnayg5k2y04lenk54unf5md425x85gaff3chu0989tj7mvr8rje9qqf2hkht"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844888,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"minimalsink66\"],[\"amount\",\"32000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[3].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"6109022666c56437445ba84175f6ccc8ef91d8c2cccf14cbcc4060a3d15b27ff\",\"sig\":\"dc59495eb134a1446f3423b33c770d96750ae7c31ad3aecf52818c1b7f481e991316b4f7b5d15081132cf42df8077b154839ca36d5e9339117eb982d6cd2e62c\"}"],["preimage","d27b69e4feedcb8407104d8192d63c119cfdb5905e29937f43be2794c643b36c"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"a864e19e925bce1ed8f1ef0cde918e55182f6b1e93ac37a8c09b3cdf60d6e6e4","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"5651c0b9fc6bb0950534f67db8f16c58958966833d0eb315b962684f22b622966d858303e454a495f01a0723c6d5fee639a4aaddbecdbefd2d32872e775523e7","tags":[["p","2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc"],["bolt11","lnbc220n1pjqrcvmpp5uf5svph5snesx5jrchjjevxum023t3wfk3fnvyevfkvfvwsh07lshp5zlz2mflru26grw6jy9450eavtrqd95egs8a2jxa6kmqfwgkhxlcscqzpgxqzfvsp59jgkqte57rzj34wdea7g502eufv56yt4wy3ftddtm6gcalvz8vxq9qyyssq43jfpsryh6ryua0gnekghm0j4le7706c6tprry86q82zpnzcx66qe6nhrdg22j4dqmwm5h7gd38lwqfrjkcjxujx4ur327nvj8v2kusq2jpzxx"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844890,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"grimyend76\"],[\"amount\",\"22000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[4].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"47234ce73a5a2563dce90507bc9ac237d02c9adf3699f784ce1fb6f2e608335a\",\"sig\":\"e788057275671a404b67fb1dece2673bda01915727ed960de11f77865a9e3d78e18f590119ef0296401ff7f35053ffad67f37583aedf28641e8037d26a1e3d06\"}"],["preimage","e2690606f484f3035243c5e52cb0dcdbd515c5c9b45336132c4d98963a177fbf"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"8ecc76eff7ff9d52d54d111698624ff1afd2db04645c41253596fcd12bbd696e","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"f1c2b9317f58509a2d5031676a4bddf3f07747af33b834e22c285ce7da870a9b4bc4c564679212ce668745e73da8fc18236fcb939b27d1ae81efbf8e937f6367","tags":[["p","ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7"],["bolt11","lnbc320n1pjqrcvepp56fakne87ah9cgpcsfkqe943uzxw0mdvstc5exl6rhcnef3jrkdkqhp56gydzwmjx76tu9qkz4e8cda6rytslmcwkfgqzz9acuz9kdqux7uqcqzpgxqzfvsp56cqkq9vtnk329qjele4fd3g9d3cvfhqqdx3p0s0t4tx9lcyr39tq9qyyssq4fhedpy4m0jqg3pgj0q0cksqfql5d99r6ag4t85pn2e2t5kv9xmnayg5k2y04lenk54unf5md425x85gaff3chu0989tj7mvr8rje9qqf2hkht"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844888,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"minimalsink66\"],[\"amount\",\"32000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[5].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"6109022666c56437445ba84175f6ccc8ef91d8c2cccf14cbcc4060a3d15b27ff\",\"sig\":\"dc59495eb134a1446f3423b33c770d96750ae7c31ad3aecf52818c1b7f481e991316b4f7b5d15081132cf42df8077b154839ca36d5e9339117eb982d6cd2e62c\"}"],["preimage","d27b69e4feedcb8407104d8192d63c119cfdb5905e29937f43be2794c643b36c"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"a864e19e925bce1ed8f1ef0cde918e55182f6b1e93ac37a8c09b3cdf60d6e6e4","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"5651c0b9fc6bb0950534f67db8f16c58958966833d0eb315b962684f22b622966d858303e454a495f01a0723c6d5fee639a4aaddbecdbefd2d32872e775523e7","tags":[["p","2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc"],["bolt11","lnbc220n1pjqrcvmpp5uf5svph5snesx5jrchjjevxum023t3wfk3fnvyevfkvfvwsh07lshp5zlz2mflru26grw6jy9450eavtrqd95egs8a2jxa6kmqfwgkhxlcscqzpgxqzfvsp59jgkqte57rzj34wdea7g502eufv56yt4wy3ftddtm6gcalvz8vxq9qyyssq43jfpsryh6ryua0gnekghm0j4le7706c6tprry86q82zpnzcx66qe6nhrdg22j4dqmwm5h7gd38lwqfrjkcjxujx4ur327nvj8v2kusq2jpzxx"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844890,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"grimyend76\"],[\"amount\",\"22000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[6].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"47234ce73a5a2563dce90507bc9ac237d02c9adf3699f784ce1fb6f2e608335a\",\"sig\":\"e788057275671a404b67fb1dece2673bda01915727ed960de11f77865a9e3d78e18f590119ef0296401ff7f35053ffad67f37583aedf28641e8037d26a1e3d06\"}"],["preimage","e2690606f484f3035243c5e52cb0dcdbd515c5c9b45336132c4d98963a177fbf"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"8ecc76eff7ff9d52d54d111698624ff1afd2db04645c41253596fcd12bbd696e","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"f1c2b9317f58509a2d5031676a4bddf3f07747af33b834e22c285ce7da870a9b4bc4c564679212ce668745e73da8fc18236fcb939b27d1ae81efbf8e937f6367","tags":[["p","ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7"],["bolt11","lnbc320n1pjqrcvepp56fakne87ah9cgpcsfkqe943uzxw0mdvstc5exl6rhcnef3jrkdkqhp56gydzwmjx76tu9qkz4e8cda6rytslmcwkfgqzz9acuz9kdqux7uqcqzpgxqzfvsp56cqkq9vtnk329qjele4fd3g9d3cvfhqqdx3p0s0t4tx9lcyr39tq9qyyssq4fhedpy4m0jqg3pgj0q0cksqfql5d99r6ag4t85pn2e2t5kv9xmnayg5k2y04lenk54unf5md425x85gaff3chu0989tj7mvr8rje9qqf2hkht"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844888,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"minimalsink66\"],[\"amount\",\"32000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[7].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"6109022666c56437445ba84175f6ccc8ef91d8c2cccf14cbcc4060a3d15b27ff\",\"sig\":\"dc59495eb134a1446f3423b33c770d96750ae7c31ad3aecf52818c1b7f481e991316b4f7b5d15081132cf42df8077b154839ca36d5e9339117eb982d6cd2e62c\"}"],["preimage","d27b69e4feedcb8407104d8192d63c119cfdb5905e29937f43be2794c643b36c"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"a864e19e925bce1ed8f1ef0cde918e55182f6b1e93ac37a8c09b3cdf60d6e6e4","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"5651c0b9fc6bb0950534f67db8f16c58958966833d0eb315b962684f22b622966d858303e454a495f01a0723c6d5fee639a4aaddbecdbefd2d32872e775523e7","tags":[["p","2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc"],["bolt11","lnbc220n1pjqrcvmpp5uf5svph5snesx5jrchjjevxum023t3wfk3fnvyevfkvfvwsh07lshp5zlz2mflru26grw6jy9450eavtrqd95egs8a2jxa6kmqfwgkhxlcscqzpgxqzfvsp59jgkqte57rzj34wdea7g502eufv56yt4wy3ftddtm6gcalvz8vxq9qyyssq43jfpsryh6ryua0gnekghm0j4le7706c6tprry86q82zpnzcx66qe6nhrdg22j4dqmwm5h7gd38lwqfrjkcjxujx4ur327nvj8v2kusq2jpzxx"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844890,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"grimyend76\"],[\"amount\",\"22000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[8].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"47234ce73a5a2563dce90507bc9ac237d02c9adf3699f784ce1fb6f2e608335a\",\"sig\":\"e788057275671a404b67fb1dece2673bda01915727ed960de11f77865a9e3d78e18f590119ef0296401ff7f35053ffad67f37583aedf28641e8037d26a1e3d06\"}"],["preimage","e2690606f484f3035243c5e52cb0dcdbd515c5c9b45336132c4d98963a177fbf"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"8ecc76eff7ff9d52d54d111698624ff1afd2db04645c41253596fcd12bbd696e","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"f1c2b9317f58509a2d5031676a4bddf3f07747af33b834e22c285ce7da870a9b4bc4c564679212ce668745e73da8fc18236fcb939b27d1ae81efbf8e937f6367","tags":[["p","ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7"],["bolt11","lnbc320n1pjqrcvepp56fakne87ah9cgpcsfkqe943uzxw0mdvstc5exl6rhcnef3jrkdkqhp56gydzwmjx76tu9qkz4e8cda6rytslmcwkfgqzz9acuz9kdqux7uqcqzpgxqzfvsp56cqkq9vtnk329qjele4fd3g9d3cvfhqqdx3p0s0t4tx9lcyr39tq9qyyssq4fhedpy4m0jqg3pgj0q0cksqfql5d99r6ag4t85pn2e2t5kv9xmnayg5k2y04lenk54unf5md425x85gaff3chu0989tj7mvr8rje9qqf2hkht"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844888,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"minimalsink66\"],[\"amount\",\"32000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[9].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"6109022666c56437445ba84175f6ccc8ef91d8c2cccf14cbcc4060a3d15b27ff\",\"sig\":\"dc59495eb134a1446f3423b33c770d96750ae7c31ad3aecf52818c1b7f481e991316b4f7b5d15081132cf42df8077b154839ca36d5e9339117eb982d6cd2e62c\"}"],["preimage","d27b69e4feedcb8407104d8192d63c119cfdb5905e29937f43be2794c643b36c"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"a864e19e925bce1ed8f1ef0cde918e55182f6b1e93ac37a8c09b3cdf60d6e6e4","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"5651c0b9fc6bb0950534f67db8f16c58958966833d0eb315b962684f22b622966d858303e454a495f01a0723c6d5fee639a4aaddbecdbefd2d32872e775523e7","tags":[["p","2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc"],["bolt11","lnbc220n1pjqrcvmpp5uf5svph5snesx5jrchjjevxum023t3wfk3fnvyevfkvfvwsh07lshp5zlz2mflru26grw6jy9450eavtrqd95egs8a2jxa6kmqfwgkhxlcscqzpgxqzfvsp59jgkqte57rzj34wdea7g502eufv56yt4wy3ftddtm6gcalvz8vxq9qyyssq43jfpsryh6ryua0gnekghm0j4le7706c6tprry86q82zpnzcx66qe6nhrdg22j4dqmwm5h7gd38lwqfrjkcjxujx4ur327nvj8v2kusq2jpzxx"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844890,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"grimyend76\"],[\"amount\",\"22000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[10].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"47234ce73a5a2563dce90507bc9ac237d02c9adf3699f784ce1fb6f2e608335a\",\"sig\":\"e788057275671a404b67fb1dece2673bda01915727ed960de11f77865a9e3d78e18f590119ef0296401ff7f35053ffad67f37583aedf28641e8037d26a1e3d06\"}"],["preimage","e2690606f484f3035243c5e52cb0dcdbd515c5c9b45336132c4d98963a177fbf"]]}]

["EVENT","ms-past",{"content":"","created_at":1677844901,"id":"8ecc76eff7ff9d52d54d111698624ff1afd2db04645c41253596fcd12bbd696e","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","sig":"f1c2b9317f58509a2d5031676a4bddf3f07747af33b834e22c285ce7da870a9b4bc4c564679212ce668745e73da8fc18236fcb939b27d1ae81efbf8e937f6367","tags":[["p","ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7"],["bolt11","lnbc320n1pjqrcvepp56fakne87ah9cgpcsfkqe943uzxw0mdvstc5exl6rhcnef3jrkdkqhp56gydzwmjx76tu9qkz4e8cda6rytslmcwkfgqzz9acuz9kdqux7uqcqzpgxqzfvsp56cqkq9vtnk329qjele4fd3g9d3cvfhqqdx3p0s0t4tx9lcyr39tq9qyyssq4fhedpy4m0jqg3pgj0q0cksqfql5d99r6ag4t85pn2e2t5kv9xmnayg5k2y04lenk54unf5md425x85gaff3chu0989tj7mvr8rje9qqf2hkht"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844888,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"ef72be13f5cb3c62fc5ab963f9c4c5effb5f2ec2400a40cbb33db211742e21b7\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"minimalsink66\"],[\"amount\",\"32000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[11].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"6109022666c56437445ba84175f6ccc8ef91d8c2cccf14cbcc4060a3d15b27ff\",\"sig\":\"dc59495eb134a1446f3423b33c770d96750ae7c31ad3aecf52818c1b7f481e991316b4f7b5d15081132cf42df8077b154839ca36d5e9339117eb982d6cd2e62c\"}"],["preimage","d27b69e4feedcb8407104d8192d63c119cfdb5905e29937f43be2794c643b36c"]]}]

Could please check again?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

It no longer seems to loop endlessly. I get one batch of events from the "since" to the "until" and then and EOSE, and nothing else.

If "since" == "until" then no events are delivered, and no EOSE comes, even though there are events with that time code.

For example this REQ delivers no events and no EOSE:

["REQ","ms-past",{"since":1677844901,"until":1677844901}]

However, there are events with the ...901 time code (that I got with a different query) e.g.

["EVENT","ms-past",{"id":"a864e19e925bce1ed8f1ef0cde918e55182f6b1e93ac37a8c09b3cdf60d6e6e4","kind":9735,"pubkey":"be1d89794bf92de5dd64c1e60f6a2c70c140abac9932418fee30c5c637fe9479","created_at":1677844901,"content":"","tags":[["p","2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc"],["bolt11","lnbc220n1pjqrcvmpp5uf5svph5snesx5jrchjjevxum023t3wfk3fnvyevfkvfvwsh07lshp5zlz2mflru26grw6jy9450eavtrqd95egs8a2jxa6kmqfwgkhxlcscqzpgxqzfvsp59jgkqte57rzj34wdea7g502eufv56yt4wy3ftddtm6gcalvz8vxq9qyyssq43jfpsryh6ryua0gnekghm0j4le7706c6tprry86q82zpnzcx66qe6nhrdg22j4dqmwm5h7gd38lwqfrjkcjxujx4ur327nvj8v2kusq2jpzxx"],["description","{\"kind\":9734,\"created_at\":1677844890,\"tags\":[[\"p\",\"2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc\"],[\"relays\",\"wss://nostr-pub.wellorder.net\",\"wss://relay.damus.io\",\"wss://nostr.jatm.link\",\"wss://nostr-relay.nokotaro.com\",\"wss://nostr-relay.aapi.me\",\"wss://nostr.21crypto.ch\",\"wss://relay.snort.social\"],[\"user\",\"grimyend76\"],[\"amount\",\"22000\"]],\"content\":\"providing zaps for free | donate: zappr#[15].dev\",\"pubkey\":\"c6ee20a53f29409e1d0bb39edf6d0d3377e9a7133aba4d467db83f8d33d0ea06\",\"id\":\"47234ce73a5a2563dce90507bc9ac237d02c9adf3699f784ce1fb6f2e608335a\",\"sig\":\"e788057275671a404b67fb1dece2673bda01915727ed960de11f77865a9e3d78e18f590119ef0296401ff7f35053ffad67f37583aedf28641e8037d26a1e3d06\"}"],["preimage","e2690606f484f3035243c5e52cb0dcdbd515c5c9b45336132c4d98963a177fbf"]],"sig":"5651c0b9fc6bb0950534f67db8f16c58958966833d0eb315b962684f22b622966d858303e454a495f01a0723c6d5fee639a4aaddbecdbefd2d32872e775523e7"}]

>From: cameri at 03/05/23 08:21:14 on wss://atlas.nostr.land

>---------------

>Could please check again?

The issue was a misconfigured mirror. Eden runs 5 relay instances behind the scenes and must be kept in sync. At some point we configured the mirror and formed a loop. The messages in the loop were the last 1000 events before the mirror started.

I’m working on some changes for Nostream to include the number of max hops an event can be re-broadcasted so this doesn’t happen again.

...Remember Knight Capital! ;-)

>From: cameri at 03/05/23 09:53:12 on wss://atlas.nostr.land

>---------------

>The issue was a misconfigured mirror. Eden runs 5 relay instances behind the scenes and must be kept in sync. At some point we configured the mirror and formed a loop. The messages in the loop were the last 1000 events before the mirror started.

>

>I’m working on some changes for Nostream to include the number of max hops an event can be re-broadcasted so this doesn’t happen again.