You can also use the Caddy webserver as a reverse proxy with Cloudflare as your DNS, pointing to your Tailscale IP. A bit more involved but flexible.
Discussion
Yeah. Few ways to do it.
Just annoying that they ninja enabled that. Took me a while to figure out why my shit wasn't working. Thought my server was screwed up.
Yup same here, I know the feeling. It always seems to happen at the worst time too.
I wish everything was just a toggle option for a couple releases and it was made apart that they were going to change defaults.