"so everything you listed only has value because others decide to want it and they have relative scarcity?"

is not contradicted by

"Value is tied to utility and desire, not just scarcity."

also

"Liquidity ≠ inherent value"

nobody claimed that. my actual claim was without scarcity, there is no value to speak of. it's true that price is a proxy for value. it's also true that values is subjective and situational.