What he was describing was clearly interest.

1) Someone wants to build something that costs 100 BTC to build.

2) He asks someone with 100 BTC to borrow the money.

3) They give him the money and he promises to return the entire 100 BTC and add 1% on top.

4) He spends X years building.

5) He finishes, gets 101 BTC and returns it.

6) Lender pockets 1% profit.

My point was:

Where does the 101 Bitcoin come from, that he pays back?

How hard is it to scrape together 101 Bitcoin after X years (when the purchasing power has increased), while building something?

Under fiat, he simply takes out a different loan to repay the 101 Bitcoin and then he just keeps rolling that debt over into longer and longer-dated loans and other financial magic. Or he has a huge stock sale to astronomic prices. Or etc.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I still think deflation could stabilize enough to allow profitable loans again, maybe in our lifetimes, but halal loans sound more compatible in general with a world where there's a deflationary currency

Because it's based upon a gold standard, where inflation hardly ever goes over 3%, so you can make good money just charging a fee. The longer the loan span, the higher the fee. And if they can't pay up, you just keep the collateral.

That doesn't work for building something like a cathedral, unless you have some similarly-valuable asset, like a second cathedral or a full gold vault.

there has never been and never will be a deflationary currency until bitcoin stops emitting new tokens

just should point that out... the supply of gold increases and has increased at 1-3% for all of recorded history by estimation, based on the sales of new gold from miners

i'm a tail emissions guy, so, my pet theory is that when the current precision of bitcoin is untenable it will be upgraded and emissions will continue at the same rate, most likely, just that previously there was nothing smaller than 1 sat... there is already millisats in LN protocol and as Mises points out, a fixed currency base does not preclude price calculation, in fact it makes it easier

Bitcoin is definitely deflationary. Coins are lost faster than new ones are made, the total supply therefore decreases.