7/ @umbrel
Pros
+ Nice interface
+ Probably the most popular node (and the one I've had the longest) so there is a large support community
+ Biggest selection of applications, also has apps not available on other nodes like Nostr Wallet Connect from @getAlby
Cons
- Telemetry collected seems unneeded and a privacy concern. https://twitter.com/runcitadel/status/1680227793106247681
- Connecting wallets can be confusing (Bitcoin Core, Electrs, Lightning)
- It is currently in beta and is not considered secure. Would not use as a primary node. https://github.com/getumbrel/umbrel/blob/master/SECURITY.md
Neutral:
~ Home server approach
Software versions on 12 July 2023:
Bitcoin Core: 25.0
Mempool: 2.5.0
Specter: 1.14.2
8/ Citadel
Pros
+ Https: local network communication is encrypted, though it needs to be setup
+ FOSS (free and open-source software)
+ Big focus on privacy
Cons
- Still in heavy development, and lacking many apps (temporary)
Neutral
~ Though still in development, it is very promising. With the release of Nirvati I expect this to be a top tier node
~ Home server approach
Software versions on 12 July 2023:
Bitcoin Core: 25.0.0
Mempool: NA
Specter: 2.0.1
/9 What is my favorite? They all have pros and cons, but I do have some preferred nodes:
1. StartOS - Currenty is my main node and the one I use the most
2. RaspiBlitz - I just love the screen, and love looking at it every time I walk by it
3. Citadel - Still in the early development phases, it resembles the first versions of Umbrel, though with better privacy. I really look forward to the Nirvati release, good chance this becomes one of my top 2
4. @umbrel - My first node and still in use for apps not available elsewhere, but the security and privacy issues, + switch to home server are a turn off.
5. MyNode - The license requirement can be a turn off for some, but an advantage is that it is bitcoin only node
