I’m kinda indifferent to #1 but it’s definitively purple.

The later is a magenta / fuchsia that is questionably pink.

maybe light mode needs a more true purple (#1 very close already)

Hex #6A0DAD

RGB 106, 13, 173

And dark mode needs something lighter

Thistle

Hex #D8BFD8

RGB 216, 191, 216

Plum

Hex #DDA0DD

RGB 221, 160, 221

Colors listed above are also just examples not in love or tested any of them