No it wouldn’t be evidence because you can always direct the same question at God. What intervention of sentient beings created God?
Wouldn't creating life would be evidence that there was a creator, since it would be done by the intervention of sentient beings?
Either way, I would bet everything, based on what I have seen, that they will never create life.
Here are two series on abiogenesis. It's time consuming to go through though, but I think he does a great job of explaining it in depth.
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLILWudw_84t2THBvJZFyuLA0qvxwrIBDr
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLILWudw_84t22BWvWsoXCmaXNllbfJ2h7
Discussion
I won't pretend to know the answer to that.
Gotta answer the first before answering the second. Do you accept big bang as an explanation?
I don’t accept nor deny the Big Bang. Mostly because it doesn’t really matter to me or affect how I live my life. But my position on that is irrelevant. Even if the Big Bang theory is wrong, that doesn’t make creationism correct by default. Just because I don’t have the answers, doesn’t mean religions answers are correct.
Was a simple yes or no. Wasnt some type of gotcha or anything. Just having conversation
We don't need to provide an alternative explanation when falsifying a preexisting one, 'Falsification is independent of replacement."
Exposing the fraud of abiogenisis doesn't mean we have to offer up an alternative explanation. Saying that, if you falsify something that is the basis on which other theories of 'science' are built upon, then logically, those theories are also invalidated.
This is why I believe people find it difficult to concede any points that go against their beliefs, because they know what a single concession can lead to - having to rethink and reexamine many of our foundational beliefs and understandings. I've been there, and I have become much less resistant to changing my mind, even if my newly adopted belief/understanding is incorrect.
Oh I know you don’t need to provide an alternative explanation. This was my op lol
nostr:note1mguqdqkjcszt7rqkfax2r2n0zet5944jfpj8mvc3045sk7kskxuqnfud7d
True, although my point is they are further from creating life than they have ever been if you listen to what they claim to have done so far. While it may not be true, the next best explanation would be a creator. Whether that is a god or something else, my current opinion as a former hardcore atheist is that something created and put us here, but we'll only understand that better once we move on from this place.
Well I know they said they birthed a lamb from an artificial womb in a lab and they are trying to create wombs for human babies now too. Idk if these things are all lies but it seems legit