I hear you. However, state-by-state laws on Bitcoin will not cover federal regulation or transactions sent out of state or country. The receivers of said transactions are still subject to the laws of their local jurisdiction or country.

Marijuana legality in the US on a state by state level is admittedly not a 1-1 exact comparison here, but it will serve as a similar example:

Marijuana is still illegal on a federal level. Just because Marijuana is legal in one state, does not mean you can travel or use it in another state where it is illegal, or ship it to a country where it is illegal. Medical marijuana cards are issued at the state level and are typically only valid for use within that state. Traveling within the United States with medical marijuana is typically only legal if a reciprocity program exists.

You know I love you GLACA, so let's agree to disagree here. The Samurai folks (charged with money laundering and Unlicensed Money Transmitting offenses) might also disagree with you about the current state of Bitcoin, privacy, and regulation.

"Because of the company’s disregard for regulation, it’s alleged that Samourai Wallet laundered more than $100 million in criminal proceeds."

*Warning, this link goes to a gov site:*

https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/founders-and-ceo-cryptocurrency-mixing-service-arrested-and-charged-money-laundering

According to the US gov:

"Engaging in a money-transmitting business without being duly licensed or registering the company by federal regulations is a serious federal crime under Title 18 U.S. Code 1960.

18 U.S.C. 1960 prohibits operating a money-transmitting business without being licensed or registered. In other words, this federal statute makes it illegal to conduct financial transactions or provide services related to transmitting funds at the foreign or interstate level without being duly licensed by an appropriate state or federal agency."

When the US decides to back the dollar with a Bitcoin reserve, it will become more regulated on a federal level in the States, as it already is and has been in other countries.

And when AI is put to work doing on-chain heuristic analysis on the Bitcoin public blockchain, even the privacy hoops some Bitcoiners go through to try and achieve some level of privacy will be of little use. This is the nature of a public blockchain without privacy baked in on a protocol level.

"The U.S. government has taken steps to regulate the cryptocurrency market, with the White House outlining a "whole-of-government strategy" to protect consumers, financial stability, and national security."

Any digital transaction that takes place on a public blockchain is even less private that the strategic use of fiat.

Here are some links to check out:

https://www.investopedia.com/news/bitcoin-has-regulation-problem/

https://www.investopedia.com/cryptocurrency-regulations-around-the-world-5202122

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I hear you and I agree. What I am saying is that it is not bitcoin that is regulated but the use of bitcoin on certain territory and that is a huge difference in my opinion.

The way CBDC will be regulated will be at protocol level. To some extend Fiat is also regulated on protocol level..cash allows for some privacy and that's why they fight it and will kill it.

As long as bitcoin itself stays decentralized and can't be regulated I think we will live long enough to get to jurisdictions that will be bitcoin oriented..probably not US.

I doubt the US dollar will be backed by Bitcoin. Fed won't allow this to happen and since it is the boss of American governments it does what suits it's criminal activity supported by Fiat.

It will be a bloody collision of Bitcoin and Fed/Central Banks. The exciting part is that they can't just shut it down..and if US won't start buying BTC as their Reserve then some else will.

If miners are "incentivized" by govs to allow only KYCed transactions to be included in the blocks well, game over. I guess they are already doing it to some extent. Read about it in a related note. I will try and find it.

There will be new miners. China mines, Russia mines, Iran mines. Miners can migrate. In worst situation the network can fork..Decentralization of Bitcoin allows for this crazy game theory where no side will be willing to destroy it.

Yeah...again..by US.

Yes, US and allies. I am sure there will be sanctions and criminalization with dealings with those countries you mentioned in thw future. Cold war 2.0 and all. And this is one of the few things that really worries me about BTC's future.

It has to go through this phase. This was to be expected and known to designers for sure. We will seek friendly jurisdictions. I believe btc will prevail.

I sincerely hope so. But hey, if I am not able to transact, because of these mother fuckers, maybe my offspring will be.

This is the way.

Thx!

im not sure that all adds up. The US holds gold as a reserve, 'supposedly'. I can go to my gold guy today and pay him cash for bullion with no paperwork, I'd or anything. He will buy my gold and silver for cash as well.

Cash-in-hand usage or cash-in-hand usage for the private purchase of bullion is not forced to take place on a public blockchain.