Hmmm, well I don't think the taxpayer knows best, either. That system keeps both operating, even if either one, Catholic vs Public, is failing.
It should be the parents choice.
Discussion
That sounds neat but in practice could get tribal
The anarchy of the free market, yes. The truth is that failing schools would die and parents would want their kids educated at schools that actually do that, not brainwashing centers. Parents have the right interests for their children. I trust them.