Replying to Avatar UNCLE ROCKSTAR

Bitcoin is money.

And it must be preserved as such. Money is the ultimate tool for distinguishing what's important from what's not. Every civilization that successfully scaled needed to invent it. Those that didn't remained stuck at a certain level, unable to deal with the information overload. Its people became lost in the games of lies and deception, as they resorted to inferior substitutes to serve as currency.

Bitcoin needs to do one thing - be a decentralized ledger tracking who owns how much value, independent of any trusted third party. That's it.

As Bitcoin continues to be increasingly successful, it's understandable that specific people will propose changes to gain more power or to shape Bitcoin to suit their specific needs. However, just because they try doesn't mean they should be allowed to. If we let Bitcoin's purpose become diluted to accommodate every use case, we'll end up pleasing none. Demand for a decentralized, always-available, general-purpose database is infinite. Everyone wants to write THEIR data into such a source of truth.

If the data they're writing represents monetary transfers of value (especially from those who have a lot of sats to those who don't) - we should absolutely encourage and facilitate this.

But if the data they're writing is a personal expression of vanity or a scheme designed to trade their 1 sat for more sats from someone else, we should absolutely call them out. More importantly, we should actively work to prevent such schemes from succeeding and from being built on top of Bitcoin.

If people want to play zero-sum games and build "decentralized world computers", Ethereum already exists. That experiment has run its course over the past decade, and even its benevolent dictator & prophet Vitalik had to admit failure and propose a new five-year plan to make Ethereum "as beautifully simple as Bitcoin".

Use Bitcoin the way you use money in your life - to focus your efforts and separate truths from lies. Help others do the same. Remember: you don't change Bitcoin; Bitcoin changes you. And those wanting monkey jpegs on the blockchain, elaborate technical experiments, personality cults, or thrilling zero-sum games should be directed toward Ethereum, Solana, Cardano, or whatever shitcoin currently boasts the largest marketing and R&D budget.

This post doesn't make a fold 🤷‍♂️ the only doubt I have is very simple and is the following: isn't bitcoin freedom before anything else? And if it's freedom, why shouldn't people be free to put monkeys in a block? 🤔

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

The problem is not to put extra data in block, but if one day this "extra data" have more value than normal money transaction. It would mean a priority given to extra data instead legit transactions.

This is the point.

If you want to put extra data, it's not fun but it's ok.

If this raise fees or avoid legit transaction, it is clearly not ok.

And the more space you give for extra data, the more use case will exist to use this place.

#bitcoin must be protected for his future and not only "hope" fees will regulated it by their own.

#btc4ever

In my opinion, bitcoin is made in a way that it regulates itself. One day it will be inappropriate to put extra data and therefore it will not be done anymore 🤷‍♂️

I don't think so. bitcoin has been updated since it was born.

And it is very important to keep it up to date.

So, i don't think the actual design protect it from bad usage, and fees are certainly not enough.

Would you pay 0.001BTC of fees to more 0,0001BTC?

For me we have to maintain a reasonable fee for transaction and this would be possible only if you prioritize money transaction, always.

And it is possible with filters and by design update.

Don't expect the design to regulate itself in the perfect way. They will be winner and looser. On which side you want to be?

The only valuable regulation are the node that don't take any fees to control transactions.

And one last thing, why, ethereum that is used for all extra data storage with fees is not more used than bitcoin ?

Eth is a shitcoin! ₿ is money 🤷‍♂️🧡

then don't expect bitcoin to stay bitcoin if nothing is done to protect it from extra usages.

Fees are and will not be enough.

Yes i agree friend 😉🤝🧡

Its not "freedom before anything else" its "peer to peer cash" before anything else. I don't want to store copies of your kiddie porn library on my start9 node, and most other people don't either. You open bitcoin up to jpegs and right away it will be a bunch of disgusting pornographty stuck on everyone's nodes until the end of time or the project fails.