What exactly do you think is happening? Do you think schools are giving kids hormones? Performing surgeries? None of that is happening. Counselors pushing kids to transition? Certainly not systemically, maaaaaybe a few fringe cases.

Closest thing to reality is them being surrounded by more open minded people than their bigoted parents and having the courage to acknowledge and express parts of themselves that were ALREADY THERE. More people are openly trans these days predominantly because of increased awareness and acceptance. So the closest thing to a nugget of truth in that meme is that your kid might be around enough people that aren't assholes that they embrace parts of themselves their judgmental parents wouldn't approve of.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

First up, let’s clear the air about what’s actually happening in schools. No one's suggesting there are secret surgeries in the gymnasium—it’s about the narratives being pushed subtly through curriculum and social climate. Human brains are not fully developed until the early twenties, meaning young minds are especially impressionable. Throwing complex and potentially harmful ideologies into that mix—like those suggesting kids should consider hormonal or surgical transitions—is risky business. 🚫

Now, about being open-minded—it’s fantastic, but let’s not confuse open-mindedness with pushing kids to make life-altering decisions before they’re ready. Encouragement should mean supporting kids to think critically and explore diverse viewpoints, not nudging them toward irreversible paths like taking hormones or surgery. These actions can have lifelong consequences, which certainly have no place in the developing minds of children and teenagers.

Discussing LGBTQ+ issues doesn’t have to mean endorsing every drastic step associated with the movement. It's crucial to differentiate between promoting acceptance and diving headlong into decisions that can profoundly alter a young person's life and well-being.

Moreover, souls are not being put in the wrong bodies

Oh word, so you got the inside scoop into how God gets things done? You've grokked His ineffable plan? Since you're clearly so in the loop, can you expand on what He has cooking with all the children with cancer? I have a close friend who would LOVE to know the reasoning behind that move.

Sure

There is no sky daddy, there are no souls, there are no "wrong bodies", cancer is (most often) a result of eating foods which we have not evolved to eat (resulting in mitochondrial disfunction, resulting in disregulated growth, resulting in genetic damage)

https://youtu.be/2KLCsg3S_x8

We have an increasing amount of evidence that being trans has some physical biological component. Here's a fresh article on the subject https://www.gilmorehealth.com/augusta-university-gender-dysphoria-in-transsexual-people-has-biological-basis/#The_biological_basis_of_sexual_dysphoria

I've also seen a shortish talk from a researcher in the field who said there have been instances of neurological evidence, too. I don't remember the details, and I can't find the specific talk without remembering them, so I unfortunately can't cite it and will have to speak a little more generally, but they found structures in the brain that corresponded to their chosen gender, NOT their assigned at birth gender.

So we do actually have some evidence for "wrong bodies" if that's how you wanna phrase it.

You have an increasing amount of evidence that souls are being put in the wrong bodies? That's incredible. Who is putting these souls in the wrong bodies? Is it some sort of demon we can fight?

Wanna try addressing the argument I actually made and cited sources for, or do you prefer the much easier straw men you're constructing?

I can appreciate that YOU don't think that's happening, but I've 100% seen claims that surgeries and hormones are happening without the parents' approval or knowledge. You seem like you're trying to keep a rational perspective, which I appreciate and respect, but please understand others on your side unfortunately are in fact that gullible and hateful, so if you stand too close, you might get confused with them occasionally.

As for being open minded vs pushing, I don't think pushing is happening in any capacity that could be described as systemic. As I said with the counselors last time, there may be a few fringe cases, but by and large, nobody is PUSHING children to become trans. A growing number of schools will provide a welcoming environment that will accept kids who claim they're trans, but that's not pushing it on them.

From my understanding, the vast majority of teens attempting to transition do it mostly without medical intervention. They wear clothing and style their hair in ways that reinforce their desired gender, maybe go by a new name they see as more gender appropriate, but surgeries are FAR from a common experience. From what I've heard, hormones are often not given yet, either, and if they are, it's typically a lengthy process involving multiple consultations with a doctor and I think in many cases a psychiatrist/psychologist.

Far more common is giving them puberty blockers so that IF AND ONLY IF the desire to transition persists long term, they can avoid puberty's massive dose of hormones corresponding to the undesired biological gender and dose themselves with the desired hormones when they get closer yo adulthood. The only risk from this that I'm aware of is lower bone density, but from my understanding, while this is somewhat concerning, it's worth pointing out that kids who DON'T transition likely won't stay on them nearly as long as kids who do, and kids who DO transition will likely find it worthwhile for at least two reasons. One, the gender dysphoria often makes them miserable, so weaker bones are a comparatively small concern at the level of impact I'm aware of. Two, they'll likely pass as their new gender even more successfully, which will significantly reduce the bigoted backlash they face.

It's possible I'm misunderstanding something, so if you have any reputable sources that can contradict anything I've said, I'm open to checking them out. But from my understanding, this concern is blown WAY out of proportion by conservative media and politicians to feed on the fears of people much more bigoted than you seem to be trying to be.