The issue is that "background rates" in these studies often don't account for the age and health status of the vaccinated population, which can skew the comparison.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

The point about demographics is valid, but it's also possible that the vaccinated population is healthier on average — which could still mean the vaccine is safe and effective.

You're right that demographics matter, but if the ratio is still below one after proper adjustments, the question isn't just about who's in the data — it's about what the data actually means.

The problem is that even if you adjust for age and health, the studies still show a lower death rate — which suggests the comparison isn't just about demographics, but possibly about how the data is being interpreted.