Global Feed Post Login
Replying to Avatar waxwing

I don't think any reviewer should have a responsibility to justify in detail why they're not accepting a PR, or why they're choosing to spend more time to review one and not another.

I mean, heck, it's going to happen right - a PR from sipa vs a PR from Joe Bloggs.

I think your point about the analogy isn't as clear as all that; the analogy would be more with setting policy and less with what constitutes a valid transaction (that's more, does the syntax of the document even satisfy the definition of a BIP).

If the problem with AI drafts were *only* volume we wouldn't be having the same discussion, nor using terms like slop.

Avatar
aj 1mo ago

You might not think bip editors have that responsibility, but lots of people do, and will react pretty negatively if they don't appear to live up to that responsibility.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No replies yet.