A few thoughts on why traditions matter, from an atheist and programming perspective.

There is a saying that traditions are solutions to problems that we have forgotten. Once traditions are removed, the problems they fixed come back.

Removing traditions can be likened to a programmer removing random lines and functions of code because he/she doesn't see what their purpose is.

The result is that the code starts malfunctioning, since the pieces of code that were removed had utility value that was forgotten.

Every programmer that returns to their own code 10 years later may delete or change vital parts of the code by mistake.

This is why programmers are reluctant to even fix a spelling error in a code that works, because downstream functions might reference that spelling as it is.

When we evaluate the value of culture and traditions that provide high degrees of social capital and societal cohesion, we must remember that they probably have a purpose, even if we don't understand it. Just as when we read code we wrote 10 years ago that we also don't fully understand.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Sounds like Jordan Peterson.

Id love to see experimentation on social order - some places being the control group, others being experimental groups

Absolutely.

I favor local sovereign jurisdictions, in the range between the size of cities, municipalities and counties, perhaps even as large as U.S. states. Abolish federal/government taxes and control. Let individuals vote with their feet between jurisductions that are responsible for their own economy. Competition, freedom and options.

The US Constitution was a centralization psyop

This seems like an argument for Christianity (or religion in general)

The Bible explains how to live and when not followed you get problems

Was actually thinking about this last night

I think there are some advantages with Christian culture, even though I am atheist. There is more cohesion, higher degrees of social capital, focus on quality art, music and architecture, and so on.

My approach is that it is best to not interfere too much with the complex code of traditions, since I have limited understanding of the results.

Basic caution to not ruin that which works.