Yes. A majority vote doesn’t make it moral to take money from the minority.
An intellectually honest person would say that they don’t believe in consensual human interaction, if they believe in taxation as a means to fund welfare.
Welfare would be most efficiently administered if it was a private business, which everyone who wanted to participate in voluntarily chose to.
Well no taxation would be entirely consensual in a functioning democracy, that's like the whole point of voting. And it's private interest groups that use their wealth and influence to render the US' democracy a farce, where the peoples money is just being poured into imperialism and nepotism. This is exactly the point I was getting at with my initial reply to Trey idk if you read that.
I play poker with my friends often. Sometimes, one friend wins the vast majority of the money. As a joke, I’ll say “let’s vote on whether [Ben] should keep his winnings, or whether we should redivide it and keep playing.
Almost everyone votes to redivide it. Would that mean that [Ben] is consenting to his money being taken?
Majority rule doesn’t make theft a just system, and it doesn’t protect individuals or small minorities from exploitation.
Also side note: America is a constitutional republic, not a democracy.
Poker is a game, a beautiful one at that with well aligned incentives. In the real world our system is broken, and the people next to the money printers are exploiting that. I think that the current welfare system is a bandaid on a bullet wound designed to perpetuate poverty, but the people who are on it need it and just gutting it would be profoundly irresponsible. Ideally I would like to live in a world without taxes, but that would require generations of rebuilding our governments and economies into institutions that genuinely serve our best interest. At the end of the day I think you're asking the wrong questions and these questions have been deceptively fed to you by your enemies. Is taxation theft? Obviously it is now, because our government is run by thieves. Why can't we oust them? Where did our tangible democratic rights go and how did they become so useless? Well, follow the money. Look at who's benefitting from it all.
Ok, I actually do agree with this take.
I try to look far ahead and I base my ideology on a future Bitcoin world, but I have no problem with printing fiat money and handing it out to poor people.
The problem I have is that the tax system is structured in a way where the middle class and average worker pays the highest percentage by far. It’s pretty painful for me to be hit with almost 20k in tax bills considering I’m 22 and a pizza cook.
I think the only politically palatable way to fix this is to lower all taxes, hopefully as close to zero as possible, and then embrace money printing until people switch to a Bitcoin standard.
