Replying to Avatar BitcoinIsFuture

Are you so blind that you can't make a difference between financial data on Bitcoin and spam data / jpegs?

Speaking about fees, didn't you see this?

... also nothing will brake, don't need to FUD

We can start with BIP110 and the tackle other challenges.
Avatar
₿rent 2d ago

We literally can’t. If BIP110 were implemented, the technique shown by the Bitmex Research article would still work. And there is no limit to similar techniques for any other bit of Bitcoin data structures. The more restrictions placed, the more insidious the data injection techniques will become. And the more difficult it will be to build needed layer 2 & 3 technologies on Bitcoin.

It is not FUD to say that arbitrary changes to data limits and relay policies are likely to break L2/3 technologies. Lookup “Lightning network ephemeral anchors” for a pertinent example.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Avatar
BitcoinIsFuture 2d ago

Thats complete BS.

First of all Bitcoin is not "data". Bitcoin is P2P ecash - Freedom Money.

Second, BIP110 will contain the major issues with spam. If we reduce it with 90%, that will still be good.

Third, there are other solutions to contain spam.

Avatar
₿rent 2d ago

Is “P2P ecash” made of wood? Glass? No, it is made of bits of data. Fundamentally, the Bitcoin blockchain is data. It represents financial transactions, contracts, identity, and unfortunately, spam.

Being made of data, there is no way to police what every bit of data represents at a macro level, in the external world. Proof of this is here, if you care about the truth.

https://www.bitmex.com/blog/the-unstoppable-jpg-in-private-keys

Avatar
BitcoinIsFuture 2d ago

wrong, there is a way

https://bip110.org/

There is also a Cat that chases spam using the spammers own rules.

Avatar
₿rent 2d ago

BIPS are discussed/assessed here:

https://github.com/bitcoin/bips