Avatar
Max 2y ago

Why does nip19 use bech32, and not bech32m?

Is the checksum bug not relevant?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Avatar
Carman 2y ago

Not really, things are pretty much fixed in length so not a big deal. Also the worst case is tagging the wrong person, not losing money.

Avatar
Max 2y ago

nprofiles can get quite large I think, but yeah, it's not as critical software.

Avatar
Sjors Provoost 2y ago

Still, why use an outdated standard with a known bug for something invented in 2023? It's a trivial fix.

Avatar
Carman 2y ago

Nostr was created in 2021

Avatar
James 2y ago

Really? Did not know that

Avatar
Max 2y ago

But the bech32 flaw was discovered before 2021 anyhow, right?