Replying to Avatar BlueDuckBTC

“When I looked harder, I realized that "the state" did not create fiat. Fiat created the state. Usury created the state to enforce and collect on debt.”

Could we look at this from an angle that profit created Fiat and profit now uses then State much like it uses the Banks? I think governing bodies is a natural manifestation of social animals, this has been observed over and over again. My default is to reject the notion of a State but let’s not inject that and let profit/capitalism be let off the hook so to speak.

“Bitcoin doesnt just fix money in the superficial sense of stopping the money printer. It breaks the whole model of the debt-based world. The whole thing breaks. Which is scary. But so is letting this continue.”

Everything leading up to this paragraph guides the reader into “Fiat is the problem” but I think it skips the vast majority of history. As Lyn Alden and many others have said, gold actually served as very good and hard money for a long period of human history, prior to technological advances rendering it useless. During these times there was still corruption, there were still those profiting off of someone else’s labor and centralizing wealth/power.

I have no doubt that #bitcoin will get us the vast majority of the way “there” but without changing ideology of profit of everything else…I’m reluctant to say Bitcoin will fix anything at all.

If Bitcoin succeeds, why is for profit capitalism the automatic winner IF it is still just a theory? Why couldn’t other systems like profit sharing, co-op, or even fully socialized industries survive perfectly fine and better than for profit capitalism?

“If Bitcoin succeeds, why is for profit capitalism the automatic winner IF it is still just a theory? Why couldn’t other systems like profit sharing, co-op, or even fully socialized industries survive perfectly fine and better than for profit capitalism?”

Because those models likely rely on a centralized authority, which definitionally suppresses the free market and is therefore likely to be outcompeted by the free market in the long run.

Sure, I could see a few small pockets of profit sharing, co-op, or full socialism on the bitcoin standard consisting of those who voluntarily choose those models.

But the desire to contribute and create value is a key component of the human condition. Most humans want to create a better future for their offspring than the present. So I’d expect the global free market to dominate, while other models survive as small boats lifted by the rising tide of the global free market on sound money.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I think so. And either way, there's no need to wrestle over theories. If people want to have a coop or put tarrifs on their border or... Whatever. Go ahead. If you think you have a better model, just try it. In some contexts, it will probably work.

Bitcoin just means you can't force it on the rest of us so easily and we can find out what really works for us in our context.

Another old word I love is "subsidiarity". We will be able to make local decisions. Not because we get everybody to agree to that as an ideology, but because that is just how things naturally work.

In a lot of ways, Bitcoin is just letting us be ourselves again. Be natural again. Be healthy again.

Once we're all out from under the yoke of the debt system, the questions will answer themselves. Freedom allows the truth to emerge.

I can buy into everything you just wrote. Which is why I contest the overwhelming sentiment that capitalism is THE answer.

Isms don't exist, man. There is no THE answer. All this isms stuff is mind control.

The world we know is a tyranny of debt. Let's just solve for that. The best thing you can do is get your own mind and energy free from it. Stop using their fake money, stop using their fake words

Fiat is word magic. Break the spell.

But capitalism relies on a central authority for property rights. I agree with human condition to create and produce but that happens naturally without profit, property rights, and does not need any market.