My kids turned into obvious dog and cat person. 3yo was previously twice bit by the dog and has still no fear. He wrestles her every morning and laughs his ass off as she sniffs it. Also he yells Boo! at the cat for fun. 4yo is afraid, cautious and reserved next to the dog. But the soft plushy cat with silent walk and purrs will get to him soon and he'll fall in love with it, I'm absolutely sure.