Hardware wallets are an unnecessary expense ($300 +) pushed by marketing, when free options provide similar or better protection:

• Paper wallets, air-gapped computers, or open-source software like Electrum can achieve true offline signing without hardware costs or trust issues.

• The seed phrase is the real key to your Bitcoin—if stored securely offline, a hardware device adds little value beyond convenience, yet introduces physical risks like loss, damage, or theft.

• In criminal contexts (e.g., cartels or illicit funds), recovery seeds can be shared to invisibly transfer assets post-seizure, bypassing blockchain traces and making hardware wallets a tool for evasion rather than pure security.

No matter how secure the device, human factors make them vulnerable:

• Phishing, fake updates, or scam letters (e.g., “urgent replacement” mails) trick users into revealing seeds or connecting to malicious apps.

• If a device fails or locks up (reported in some cases), users are stuck relying on the seed anyway, rendering the hardware redundant.

#GM #asknostr #wallets #hardwarewallets #bitcoin

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

GM!

GM to you too

These arguments look odd to me.

For example.. how is the criminal context argument a hardware issue? This is how bitcoin and cryptography work; the owner of the seed is in charge.. regardless of where that seed is stored and regardless of the owner's (in this case ill) intent. Feature, not a bug.

What are these $300+ hardware wallets? And how is getting a separate computer that you keep offline easier?

I can tell you have never used a Coldcard Q.

I agree seed phrases are the keys. That's why I launched nostr:nprofile1qqs9v5v8trgum5msr6cd82j3r77mhj94sk0adcp2232sdy65srusmdqpzdmhxue69uhhqatjwpkx2urpvuhx2ue0l39fwr 😏

Offline devices with good entropy are useful for creating seeds

#GM Fren 🌞 have an amazing day today https://youtu.be/wqCz3-v3PHA

An air gapped hardware wallet with a secure element is pure convenience, got a cheap one and wouldn't wanna miss it, though the most important part is the seed phrase in your head + proper steel backup.

Which one did you get

#SafePal S1 from back then with a special #Binance offer. Still going strong.