Avatar
frphank
47be0b2a89faaa66bc57f5c679203486da45660295cb3db3c2f38f4be8d8816e
Autopoietic. Scratching things from chaos. Homesteading the noösphere. Opportunity farmer: Reading things that are not yet on the page. Haskell. Dollars only, thanks.

I put in the npub, I get a menu selecting Bitcoin or Credit Card, I select Credit Card, then I get the above.

Surely you must have some server logs to peruse.

Replying to 21823843...

Interesting perspective. We could debate what decentralised means, but I doubt we'd ever be able to find a universal definition -- it is too much of a spectrum. If your definition of decentralised is that there are no servers at all, then I guess you'd think only purely P2P protocols are, and not even nostr would qualify. From a total purity perspective, probably anything using DNS would be disqualified too.

My view on these protocols is as follows:

Usenet has essentially the same model as nostr. Yes, there are servers (relays), but people are free to choose which ones they use. They can post their messages to any of them, and those messages may get propagated to other servers. Each server can have its own message acceptance/forwarding policies, and choose which other servers to connect with.

IRC is also a decentralised network (the R stands for relay). An IRC network consists of many different servers relaying messages. Each server agrees roughly with the rules of the wider network, but is generally free to administer its server as it sees fit (including user bans, preventing relaying certain channels, etc). Sometimes server operators disagree, and this results in them leaving the network and establishing their own. That's why there are many different IRC networks, EFnet, IRCnet, DALnet, etc.

HTTP and email are both decentralised in the sense that you don't need to get anybody's permission to connect to the network, and there are no single points of failure.

Usenet, IRC and nostr replicate data that's how they're decentralized. HTTP doesn't that's why it's so easy to censor.

Oy vey. Do they put their feet up on little stools too. The soles of their shoes might touch the ground otherwise.

Can they? No one can use Bitcoin. You can literally not buy anything with it.

Do the poor schmucks on the right know that no, they cannot use Bitcoin.