New motherboard arrived and I have confirmed that was the problem.
Wouldn't boot into the existing M.2 drive, after many attempts at rescuing it (grub2-install, copying over .mod files, etc.), I got it almost restored.
If I manually load the grub2 config file, enter the FDE password, it gets right up to when X would normally load and then it resets. I'm not sure if it's some driver causing a fault or what.