What is healthy masculinity? What is healthy femininity?

People like to go backwards and forwards over this one and I have never seen an explanation that I like, so I made my own.

To be a man or a woman is simply to have a different set of logistical challenges in life. To be a good man or a good woman is to do a good job of handling the burdens, and the privileges, of your circumstance.

The difference between men and women is pregnancy, everything else, EVERYTHING else, is downstream of that.

Men have the privilege of walking away from a pregnancy. As such, a good man is a man who chooses to take on responsibility.

Men, in general, have the privilege of being less physically vulnerable than women. As such, a good man is a man who chooses to protect those more physically vulnerable than him.

Women, in general, have the privilege of being able to create life. That’s massive. As such, a good woman is a woman who, if/when she chooses to do so, chooses to create life in a responsible, thoughtful, and loving way.

A good woman is a person who is aware of, and respectful of, the burdens that men face.

A good man is a person who is aware of, and respectful of, the burdens that women face.

And of course, any individual that tries to deride, shame, or control another is a monster.

Thanks for coming to my TED talk.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

i love the way you've defined it so simply here. and you've touched on it at the most basic level. brilliant.

thanks for sharing and thanks for asking. :3

i've been thinking about some of this a lot recently. for me healthy masculinity is embracing the typical qualities—like strength, responsibility, and integrity—and expressing them through vulnerability, emotional awareness, and service. this is essentially how i look at chivalry: strength through service. this may not be so different from how you described it, but a lot more words lol :P

nostr:naddr1qvzqqqr4gupzp440lgv4hdceffc9svh4xhaxtw43mrwd4knty4q07d9nwzg3pvthqqxnzdejxcenxdfkxuenyv3cwdsgze

I agree with most of this. Good man or good woman is a declaring of character. However, biologically it is difficult for men to overcome the phenomenon of paternal uncertainty. Since maternal uncertainty does not exist, men inherently are plagued with this Byzantine generals problem with regards to fidelity and the potential that they may be raising another man’s offspring. This is where I think the character of a true masculine man is tested. It is quite the societal conundrum, but communicating the nuance is important so society does not skew too far toward toxic masculinity or it’s polar opposite toxic femininity

Ya that could be an issue, and this is where a good woman wouldn't put a dude in that situation. But, if you get into bed with a woman and she winds up pregnant, I think you have to take on some responsibility there based off the very real possibility that that is your kid.

Agreed. Moral character has taken a backseat in recent years with technology expanding opportunities and fantasy expectations for some in both genders. Here’s to hoping more people wake up to the nonsense spewed on social media and focus on just being a better person to everyone else they come in contact with

Here’s my ted meme