Bitcoin is either censorship resistant or not. Can’t know until there is a good reason to attempt censorship. Apparently the CSAM that has been in the chain since forever isn’t enough of a test, I guess.
Discussion
A common thread I’ve noticed amongst node runners who care about this is that their use cases for bitcoin would be just as well served by setting blocksonly=1 in bitcoin.conf…
I didn’t hear you continue your point about censorship…
I didn’t. Bitcoin either is or isn’t. None of the current issue of the day changes this.
What makes Bitcoin censorship resistant is decentralised mining, not filter policies. You can have the most draconian filter policies and this still won’t prevent txs from ending in blocks. Highly centralised mining in the state that currently is tho…
"Censorship-resistant" always meant "no one can stop you from sending value wherever you want to send it." It never meant sending whatever data, files, or messages you want. Allowing ultra-tiny designators to ride along with the value can perhaps be tolerated, so long as they are not viewed as a precedent for anything else. People who want to mess around or get rich quick should do it somewhere else and leave one of humanity's greatest discoveries the Hell alone.
I agree. I too want bad people to not do bad things or at least do them elsewhere. But whether or not they use bitcoin to do bad things is of no consequence to bitcoin. And if it is, we need a consensus rule change, not blocksonly mode.
Individuals controlling their own mempool is not censorship.
Totally agreed. I’m talking about the CSAM that is more and will also eventually be in the blockchain.
I suspect most of those who feel most strongly about this change would be better served by setting blocksonly=1
I just want a ledger of financial transactions ... I don't want to host your kiddie porn.
But you already do. Perhaps you should be in prison for it? I don’t think so, but a lot of people might.
No I don't.
So you don’t run a bitcoin node? Because there are illegal data stored in the blockchain.