Yes. Protestantism played a pivotal role. Martin Luther was a hero for calling out The Church wrt indulgences and other abuses, paving the way to much needed reform. And Protestants are right to recommend reading the Bible oneself rather than deferring to the interpretations and beliefs of others.

To me it seems that Protestantism has simply gone too far, and has lost the way of tradition in favor of the way of modernity and secularism. Most Protestant churches I’ve seen lately have rainbow flags or blm or vaccine posters or whatever is currently in vogue. And they lack mysticism, feeling more like a city council meeting than a unification with the divine. Catholic and Orthodox are closer to following the church that St. Peter founded.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Much of the Church is in a bad way right now for sure, but what you are describing sounds like mostly mainline churches which went astray long ago and are mostly hollowed out. I really don't consider them churches or really a true or meaningful part of Protestantism.

There are still faithful spiritual enclaves of Protestantism you'll find among the PCA, OPC, Lutherans, CREC, Reformed Baptists, etc.

One note regarding the earlier discussion of the crusades and a lot of Christendom past—much of the Protestant Church, even the solid churches and denoms, do often make the mistake of ignoring the first 1500 years of church history at best, denigrating a lot of it at worst. This is something I would like to see change, and am indeed seeing a slow change. We ought not be so quick to disdain and disavow our fathers.

The 'church' is a business. The 'congregation' is Christ's Body. There is a difference, and the Word of God makes that very clear, for anyone who seeks it.

Where do you see the Scriptures making a distinction between Christ's body the church?

I am suggesting that there is a (church business) man of lawlessness and rebellion who operates in secret, sending misleading doctrine forth. We should be on the watch, and not be condoning these teachings. -2Thesalonians

Admittedly I'm not sure how you see 2 Thessalonians making any such point about the church. Nor do I see any division between church and congregation in the NT or any condemnation of the institution of the Church as a business.

I do think many modern churches *function* too much like businesses (overly focused on marketing campaigns, brandong, and numbers of congregants, corporate leadership structure rather than biblically modeled elder board, etc) but that's not the same as saying the institution of the Church or any local church *is* a business.

Correct me if I have misunderstood what you are saying.

I was compelled to post with the hope that people would ponder these things, to see if they are so. I think each congregation does the best they can, but the church business leadership drive the bus so to speak, and there comes a time when the congregation has have to flee. Acts17:11, Isaiah42:18, Mark11:15, Matt23:1-5, Matt7:15-16, Matt10:16-23, 2Thesalonians