《国际空间站视频的第二条回复》
谢谢大家的捧场,看来我已经和各种谬论正面交锋了。又有人回复我,说:“你在开玩笑吗?有数不清的有星星的太空照片。” (如图)
我觉得这样正面辩论很好,在理的人是不怕辩论的。就是要把这一切错误的反驳都用不可辩驳的事实和逻辑压倒。
下面是我的回复。我觉得关键点在于:所有“该有星星的天空”必须全都有星星,才是真的。我说这个视频里“该有星星的天空”没有星星,而他却在说“其它地方的照片里有星星”。明白了吗?这是在转移话题,混淆逻辑。所有该有星星的天空都必须有星星——这是一个逻辑 AND,而很多人把它混淆为逻辑 OR,这样缺乏逻辑思维弱能力的人就被迷惑了。
而且你只需要搜索一下网络,就会发现其它的“实拍”太空照片和视频里,绝大部分“该有星星的天空”都没有星星。所以这个人显然没有仔细看过其它照片和视频,或者是故意在这里混淆事实。不实际去看的人也许就被迷惑了。
另外,我估计他所谓的“有星星的太空照片”,都是那些“太空望远镜照片”。那些照片里的“星星”都是我们从来没见过的,极其遥远的星系。为什么我们从来没有看到过它们拍到含有北斗七星的照片,银河的照片?想想这是怎么回事吧。因为我们从来没有亲眼见过那些星系,所以可以随便用 Photoshop 画出来,就告诉你那是“太空望远镜”拍的。
Do you mean those taken by Hubble or Webb space telescopes? I don't mean those photos of obscure galaxies which we have never seen with our eyes. Since we have never seen them from earth with our eyes, those can be easily generated by computers or just drawn with photoshop.
I mean photos contain the stars we are familiar with like Big Dipper etc and the Milky Way, a sky full of stars. That's what we should see in the space photos and videos. We should have seen skies full of shining stars out of ISS's cupola windows. There are none.
You can't just have some photos contain stars and some don't. By the photography experience I just mentioned, all the dark skies should have at least some stars in them. But as we have seen in this video, the sky is solid black with no stars. All "real videos" (not animations) from space are like this, solid black skies containg absolutely no stars. This doesn't make sense. You just need to look at more videos, for example Hubble Servicing Mission videos and other ISS cupola videos. None of them show any stars in black skies. None.