The left one certainly doesn't look "tight" enough.
i made 2 loops to learn the weaves, i really like the one on the right better but it takes like double the time to make it, and was hard to figure out how to connect the ends
https://niscii.xyz/files/0a805311-33f3-43c4-82ca-35203658ba80
Discussion
nostr:npub12d44w9955fxcn5h4xjgzt8ur9lspgzelxu827h3cv2y9n3pwydmq8kerfl i agree, the rings are too wide for that weave. they're perfect for the right side one but way too loose for the left. i got this chart now so i know what size to make them next time :hypercat:
https://niscii.xyz/files/25cbd109-65b2-4701-b843-39eba74b955c