Monero is not money, its wannabe privacy token. Yet is has leaks and some users have been traced and arrested https://moneroleaks.xyz/

Lightning has comparable if not better privacy and is at least real money.

You can't convince me that Monero is money because it had 15+ Hard Forks and changed its algos multiple times. It also had two chain reorg attacks, it near impossible to be audited and has indefinite inflation.

As for Ethereum shitcoin? Its created out of thin air, centralized SLAVERY scam. The fact that fucking shitcoin is trying to integrate itself to Bitcoin does not make it better in any way.

nostr:nevent1qqs0wzp78gh6cjshnz0tz853e2vck6cc6ecypazh2vd2eygxzl2lcdgppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0qyg8wumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytnddakj7qgcwaehxw309aex2mrp0yhxvmm4de6xz6tw9enx6tc7ece5n

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Looked through that link you sent. The ones pertaining to fee fingerprinting are resolved in every wallet I can think of. Most don't even permit custom fees.

For Edge wallet, yeah you share your private view key which links your transactions together. This is an identical privacy tradeoff to Electrum which is a ubiquitous light wallet server used on nearly every Bitcoin wallet. The difference is in Monero only Edge wallet uses it and its well known in the community and in that software the tradeoffs that need to be commited for the enhanced performance.

The main point in that site that is a genuine attack vector is poisoned outputs in the ring signature. See nostr:nprofile1qqsdzvcpujvlj2ymrzxwc2nx99gh0x75c3dsvp32xhdzvttg73xpmgspzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezumt0d5hsz9thwden5te0wfjkccte9ejxzmt4wvhxjme08un5pz s attack of the poisoned outputs series for details on this and how to mitigate https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLk4xsazIq6TZUKDScrxFjhajOKTlHknRx

In summary, any UTXO that came from an exchange should be sent to a private wallet then sent to a new address before spending to add another ring signature between the one with a poisoned output from the exchange. This largely defeats the problem.

There's a major cryptographic upgrade to ring signatures next year called FCMP++ (Full Chain Membership Proofs) which uses ALL past outputs as the anonymity set instead of the current 16. This makes any deanonymization attack via outputs IMPOSSIBLE.

Lightning has incomparable privacy. It relies entirely on network level privacy which is already highly susceptible to timing attacks due to the hub-and-spoke model. Monero has both strong on-chain and network level privacy. Even if Dandelion++ is broken and a transaction is traced to having originated from a particular node, sender, reciever and amount privacy is still preserved. With lightning if a similar, and arguably easier, timing attack is performed than the entire transaction is revealed including amounts, sender and reciever. This is fundamentally weaker privacy and there's no convincing argument or even scenario in which this is stronger. Take that back, if Edge wallet is malicious and you're using Edge wallet (the easiest least private Monero wallet) and comparing that with an LND node spun up on a VPS accessed over Tor, paid in Monero with a node opened up to a smaller onion only peer, with a coinjoined or non-KYC UTXO THEN in this case lightning is better. That's the beat Lightning case and worse Monero case. In ANY OTHER case Monero has vastly better privacy its not comparable. While also being easier to use than Lightning mind you.

I have said this before.

Privacy is not the top priority feature that makes the money real, hard and valuable.

Its a good feature but not the top priority.

Enjoy your Monero. I will enjoy my Bitcoin.

A key aspect of money is fungibility https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/money.asp which Bitcoin lacks due to the bifurcation of "tainted" UTXOs and "clean" UTXOs. Tainted coins can't be used on any exchanges and many merchants won't take them. Gold, cash and monero are all fungible. Every Monero UTXO has no traceable history thus mamingnit as fungible as a gold atom. Privacy is crucial for money.

That is wrong. Bitcoin is fungible money. Bitcoin does not need third party. It is peer-to-peer Freedom Money and its fungible.

nostr:nevent1qqs8arhmgdy09785qcrhs0j9h394psa9ajp9pgs3nlqugv0u7ycnkmgpzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezumt0d5hsz9thwden5te0wfjkccte9ejxzmt4wvhxjme0qy2hwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtn90p5hgtnsw43z7grg78c

Utxos with different histories are nonfungible.

it isn't complicated and you can stop your internal dialogue.

BS

because obviously a 100k sat utxo straight from the miner

and a 100k sat utxo from a known DNM address

are fungible... 🙄

not the sharpest tool in the shed are you?

Read the definition of fungible money again, then try to think again. Then put in the mix the function of coinjoins.

equal units are not interchangeable. period.

you can stop with the rationalizations.

and in the same way, anyone can identify and discriminate based on coinjoin history.

BS. Who is that anyone? Bitcoin is peer-to-peer Decentralized Freedom Money that does not need ANYONE as a third party.

Your BS is ridiculous. Bitcoin is fungible money.

nostr:nevent1qqs84rdlp70j23axqv84vvhprywk8gzq2y0zzvrx0wpffs0sejq5jagppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0qyg8wumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytnddakj7qg4waehxw309ahx7um5wghx77r5wghxgetk9umjxsmp

that anyone is one of the peers of your "peer-to-peer decentralized freedom money"

if your peer can identify and discern difference between units of equal value,

it is not fungible.

repeating your dogma doesn't make it true.

1 Bitcoin = 1 Bitcoin, your BS is absolutely ridiculous

Again, you need to read the definition of fungible money and stop inventing your own BS.

lol

wah wah

not the sharpest tack in the box huh?

you should read the things you post

"Fungibility refers only to the equivalence and INDISTINGUISHABILITY of each unit of a commodity or other thing with other units of the same thing..."

if you can DISTINGUISH between utxos of the same value,

they are *not fungible by definition.

Coinjoins entered the chat long ago. #Lightning too.

both great tools

but neither make UTXOs of equal value *indistinguishable.

Bitcoin is a mirror of the Universe, a perfection better than barter. Currently now we have one in which the human construct of Money (which was imperfect) became money Fiat Currency (even more imperfect) over a massive spread of generations that could not possibly retain and or reflect upon the same.

It's insane to sleepwalk it to the same again.

Bitcoin is the perfect set of rules that allow people without permission to simply say NO!

It's been happening since the 3rd of January 2009.

No is Now is Never is forever!

#Bitcoin

cool story bro

Thank you. But reality is not a story, a story is different.

Bitcoin cannot be gamed, as such it is the default language of the ungamed.

Empathy, Love, Unity, those are the invisible alignments of exchange.

Those exchanges live within you and the recipient's, Bitcoin just makes those rules as permanent as the same rules of the Universe.

Have fun learning more about everything.

It's literally enjoyable buy default.

I hate to break it to you son

Bitcoin is the long evolution and synergy of different technologies. it's extremely well designed but it's not perfect.

it's certainly is an an expression of any universal truth.

as long as you don't see it as something designed and created by people, you can't actually analyze it in an intelligent way.

it certainly is *not an expression of any universal truth

I disagree. Here the Universe White Paper, it's mirror is the Bitcoin White Paper, Dad!

https://medium.com/@j0e810ggs/the-universe-white-paper-a089f9c83500

Here's the actual formal paper and not just an article for the average reader to understand.

https://zenodo.org/records/17942972

sorry

I don't care about your arbitrary fantasies

That's an interesting point of view. You don't need to apologise to me tho.

I didn't do it because it was necessary.

Monero protects both the merchant and the customer from the money trails.

You can check the total amount of Monero. That's good enough. Inflation in % is approaching zero because the reward is constant. It also secures the network, even after 2140. Dynamic block size with associated costs also solves urgent problems that Bitcoin is putting off and BCH solved bad. Hard forks are not a bad thing if there is no chain split, and even if there is, Darwin takes care of it. In other words, Monero is damn sexy.