Are ZBD users allowed to export their nsec and use another client? nostr:npub1rvg76s0gz535txd9ypg2dfqv0x7a80ar6e096j3v343xdxyrt4ksmkxrck nostr:npub1akngghxzy6d75y8szp6y44u5pxktwy5aj6zh6jl3ncp8d93fj2fq5mfxa8 nostr:npub180cvv07tjdrrgpa0j7j7tmnyl2yr6yr7l8j4s3evf6u64th6gkwsyjh6w6

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No.

Does that mean it's coming soon or it's going to be something that isn't your NSEC?

That's a good question.

I have a long answer written out for you. I feel like a lot of people are making assumptions here 🤣 remember y’all, we’re building in public 🤣🤘

Thank you for this. I didn’t really understand the ā€œbuilding in publicā€ aspect. The greater the excitement, the greater the impatience, I think. šŸ’œšŸ‘šŸ«‚ ?cid=586b07f0947hseq7h5vasbte04w3nvd8ekfld4h9k9vv5oy6&ep=v1_gifs_search&rid=200w.gif&ct=g

Yeah honestly it makes me sad to see people assume that just because ZBD doesn’t have something now, it never will have it in the future. We only released social this early because we figured we’d give our users exactly what they want. Not everyone gets it and that’s ok i guess.

It’s just that our whole team wants to deliver something wonderful to people and that has to be done thoughtfully, not in haste šŸ’–šŸ«”

Appreciate you as an OG!!!

I don’t think that assumption is out there. I think it’s more a Veruca Salt mentality and the fact that people are used to final product being delivered in its end state. ā€œEarly adopterā€ still meant using a final product for most folks.

Nostr and the apps that interact with it are so new, so proto, so Wild West that the city slickers that come out (me included) expect there to be more infrastructure and amenities.

Thank you to all at ZBD for your efforts and patience with us users. šŸ«”šŸ«‚šŸ’œ ?cid=586b07f0rhkgqe3zqno1noghami8n7xsvc7hqcg2hxhlxznp&ep=v1_gifs_search&rid=200w.gif&ct=g

I've been on Nostr for 9 months now. I've seen Nostr grow at breakneck speeds. Most users across Nostr assume that no client is feature complete. Most of us assume that client's features are going to be missing, broken, and improving on a daily basis.

The questions came about with ZBD because it's the first Nostr client to be closed source and manage Nostr private keys for users. That's different than anything we've seen before. Because of this, we're cautious and asking questions because we want wants best for the entire protocol and all apps across the ecosystem.

For me on a personal level, I recommend apps to people on a daily basis. I get public and private questions about Nostr clients. I can't recommend something to someone if I haven't used the client or if I don't know it's insides and outsides. If I was given access to ZBD, I'd do what I always do, I'd create a burner account and play around. But since I can't, I'm asking here in public to get some answers. šŸ¤™šŸ»

Anyone who has been here 9 months is in an entirely different class than me and (I’m guessing) quite a few of those of us onboarded via ZBD. 🫔

The easier it is to come into the Nostrverse (and ZBD made it easy and fun and rewarding), the more ā€˜users’ there will be who have different assumptions than the coders and builders who came before.

(Continued in next comment because I maxed out my character count … )

For example, @samsamskies replied with 3 ways to zap at a note level from a Nostr client. 1 way involved GitHub, which as a non-coder I avoid. The other 2 were websites. Both had terms I have no idea what to do with.

I’m sure you’d could easily use any of the 3. I assume he thought I could too. Coders are amazing folks… who sometimes assume a level of technical proficiency some of us just don’t have.

I think ZBD is trying to help their user ā€˜users’ and it’s a different path.

ZBD has a character limit? Definitely try other clients and expand your horizons. I've never seen that on any other Nostr app. I wonder why ZBD made that decision?

I put in a request for a larger limit so I could post my microfiction as text. I didn’t know other clients don’t have limits.

I use Damus for things ZBD is still working on, but I can only look, not like/zap/post because I don’t have my nsec yet.

Been thinking about creating another account, but not sure I want to keep up with two. I know I’m in a small garden; that mostly works for me right now.

When something says coming soon how do you read that as ā€œnoā€

I’m curious why it was built like that from the beginning tho?

I just responded a long answer to the OG post. Lmk if that answers your question

Because as of right now that is the truth. The key is not exportable.

I’ve requested it in their Feature forum and asked via a support ticket. I’m constantly in Damus for the notifications, but I love being able to zap at a note level in ZBD. Would really like to be able to use the same keys for other Nostr things, but can’t yet.

GREAT QUESTION!

We’ve got so much stuff in the pipeline it’s crazy. Short answer, yes it’s going to be possible to use your nsec on other clients.

Long answer;

The ZBD client is not complete yet, but we never said it was ;) we’re building in public so we can gauge the interest of certain features that our users actually want to use.

With that said, developing a nostr client that is user friendly doesn’t happen in a day.

We are prioritizing features that our users want (like better DMs, better discovery, debugging, etc) and thoughtfully building out a UI and UX for our users to really feel comfortable using a private key.

A lot of people don’t know how to do that - it’s not intuitive and a bit scary. So we want to make sure that our users’ experience is not scary but fun and empowering.

We’re moving at the speed of light to make a friendly nostr client. We love every other client out there and want our users to feel comfortable venturing out into the nostr verse with ease. But right now, it’s a bit tricky to introduce already this new concept of social media AND THEN the concept of having to hold this weird password that will only appear once blah blah. One step at a time.

I feel like there’s a lot of blind idealism floating around and I’m here to say this: nostr is about optionality. We’re going to give our users the option to use anything that runs on nostr, but we cannot just randomly do it: we need to do it the right way.

Thank you for this. I appreciate the transparency šŸ«‚šŸ’œšŸ¤™šŸ»

Ofc man! I love that you asked us instead of assuming that we’re sus 🤣 that’s literally the opposite of what this team is.

It's the Bitcoiner way to not trust and ask for verification šŸ„¹šŸ¤šŸ»

Thank you. I appreciate it. Ask and ye shall receive an honest answer.

šŸ«‚

What's the deal with ZBD and requiring users to ID/doxx themselves? I remember being excited about trying it out, first couldn't sign up because I was using a VPN, then couldn't sign up because I was using a service like SimpleLogin.

Nostr/clients/relays are confusing...

lol, walled gardens always have their reasons. and they are always bad excuses.