Does any of it really matter? Not every miner in the US, let alone the rest of the world only confirm OFAC compliant transactions. Node runners are even more noncompliant. Governments are having a lot of FOMO right now. But what about consensus?

Lots of people are pondering government spurred soft forks making a mess. What about consensus driven hard forks that restore Bitcoin to people who had it confiscated by a government? What about a consensus driven hard fork that winds back all of the transactions on a government’s reserve coins that they could never get it all back?

I find laws overly restrictive. Even something like a bill of rights. I guess those are our only rights? Wrong! Asking for laws, rules or guidance is only asking for restrictions. Never forget, that the people of bitcoin run bitcoin. When governments ban a thing they only create black markets.

Don’t believe me? I’ll go buy some marijuana in a state where it’s illegal and ship it to you via the United States Postal Service. It happens every day, a lot!

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I’m not asking for rules or guidance, I’m asking for confirmation on what the govt isn’t allowed to violate, because they simply will if we don’t have something explicit to point to.

A bill or rights is not a set of rules for the people, it’s rules for the govt to fuck off essentially. They will still violate them, but establishing them clearly is a very strong part of protecting from drift in the social/political sphere.