Replying to Avatar Bitman

The OP_RETURN drama just shows how MANY people don’t understand the basics of how #Bitcoin works.

Spoiler: you can’t stop arbitrary data storage on the timechain. Trying to do so might even make things worse.

Some people are saying it's possible to "filter" spam in the mempool.

Wrong. That’s unfeasible. Anyone saying that is either misinformed or acting in bad faith.

The mempool is just local policy. Who really decides what goes into a block are the miners.

Many blindly believe influencers without understanding the fundamentals:

#Bitcoin is a decentralized database designed to store data.

Financial transactions are one type of data — not the only one.

"But shouldn’t we prioritize financial transactions?"

Yes.

"But can we stop arbitrary data from going into the timechain?"

No.

"Are there good reasons to store arbitrary data on #Bitcoin?"

Absolutely.

L2s and scalability solutions depend on on-chain proofs.

That’s just data storage.

It doesn’t matter what your node accepts or not — miners are incentivized to include these transactions and profit from them.

Financial incentives are what drive the system. Period.

If you try to become a “Bitcoin™ Defender” by running software with crazy filters...

Guess what?

The transactions go straight to the miners (with extra fees)

Small miners get left behind

Mining centralizes

People will hide the data using steganography (and you won’t even notice)

Even worse: it discourages developers.

Few people work full-time on #Bitcoin already.

Imagine having to deal with drama and FUD just to propose a basic PR?

Fewer devs = slower progress = more risk = weaker #Bitcoin.

"But what about spam?"

#Bitcoin already has a built-in antispam: fees.

Don’t want to see JPEGs or zk-proofs?

Use real #Bitcoin: spend, self-custody, join the circular economy.

You know why “spam” increased so much?

Because most people stopped using #Bitcoin on-chain.

Today it’s all custodians: Strike, Wallet of Satoshi, Liquid…

Less usage = more free space = more arbitrary data on the timechain.

Want to fix it?

More real usage → more demand for block space → higher fees → less incentive to use Bitcoin as storage.

Simple. And effective.

Want to “save #Bitcoin”?

It’s not through filtering, censorship, or hysteria.

It’s through real usage, open source, economic incentives, and freedom.

#Bitcoin is neutral. And that’s a good thing.

Bitcoin's design inherently discourages SPAM, as demonstrated by fees stabilizing at 1-5 sat/vB after the alleged "attack" on the network.

Andrew Poelstra, a renowned cryptographer and Bitcoin developer, eloquently addresses whether arbitrary data storage on Bitcoin can be prevented:

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

This dev got the point I think. We already know that Bitcoin cannot scale onchain, we even know that not everyone can self-custody and open channels just for themselft on Lightning. We need these options open to scale Bitcoin off chain while keeping freedom. It doesn't matter if not everyone can do their daily transactions on-chain, it doesn't matter that not everyone will manage lightning channels but it matter to have the freedom to do so and use any node we want to interact with Bitcoin, own node if you can afford, oncle Jim node if you are lucky to have one around, a community node where we share costs with trusted individual or even corporate managed nodes, offering acces to Bitcoin as a service for profit.

Today, with fiat, only the latter is possible, with banks or service on top of banks (Paypal and co). Bitcoin offers a better future for everyone, not because it can serves everyone directly but because it's giving freedom.

And yes, such freedommhas a cost, that it will be possible to use the network for non-financial, non-bitcoin, use cases. Maybe in 2023 it was worth doing it for some but it slowly fadr out as RoI was getting negative. Today it's a non-issue again, like for the majority of the Bitcoin block so far, it might chance again tomorrow but we cannot do much about it without hurting the ecosystem even more.

nostr:nevent1qqsz05uh37hz5rfzxye7jg3zzfwl65u85v6x4gsjgz67z7d3wv496mgpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtczyqff75vft5f2k0yumsnvkg4ahww7jx89788lnz2r7wrqaaf6gsvqxqcyqqqqqqgyd5cnp