Replying to Avatar Mike Brock

One major reason I'm pretty cool on the predictions of severe and sudden U.S. decline, is some factors nobody ever talks about.

1. The US is one of the younger countries in the world, with a growing population -- China's population is in rapid decline because of the hangover from the one-child policy. And birthrates have not recovered and continue to decline.

2. The US remains far and away the top destination for immigration in the world.

3. North America is insanely resource rich. It wouldn't be cheap or easy, but the US and Canada in particular have resources in the ground that can substitute out most mineral dependency. Including lithium and rare-earths like neodymium.

4. The US and Canada are food superpowers. Between these two countries, they produce well in excess of domestic demand, and are massive food exporters. Especially to China. China recognizes this, and has been in a rush to replace food exports from the U.S. and Canada with imports from places like Brazil. While they've made material moves here, the dependency remains very high.

5. My worries about AI aside, recent advances in artificial intelligence have demonstrated that US-based companies continue to enjoy serious advantages in terms of R&D.

These are structural advantages that were very important to the rise of the US to begin with. And they're structural advantages that persist today.

These factors matter regardless of inflation or the monetary regime.

For all of these reasons, political and moral arguments aside on whether or not the US *should* persist or decline, these factors should cause one to hedge their certainty that US collapse is certain.

Are you speaking of America, or the United States government? I think of the nation/country and the government that rules over it as not exactly the same thing (despite the "We The People" nonsense). I do agree that one may persist, while I hope the other goes the way of all governments...

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I don't think we're transitioning to anarcho-capitalism any time soon. Or ever.

I don't think 'Muricans are ready for it either. It's like when they said you can't expect a Thomas Jefferson to arise out of Iraq and create a democracy over there, because the people didn't have the cultural background for it. I fear 'Muricans have been too steeped in Statism to regain their liberties. And so, if it's not to be anarcho-capitalism, I think it will mean greater Statism trending toward totalitarianism.

I think we are tribal from a fundamental nature standpoint. It's not a matter of indoctrination. The fact we formed civilization the way we did, was path dependent from our genetics and environment. It wasn't some arbitrary idea cooked up for the benefit of a uniquely corrupt elite.