Unpopular opinion of the day:

Yes, what happened today with the #Windows infrastructure crash could also happen to #Bitcoin.

Follow me in my reasoning.

I see a lot of people criticizing centralization of the service for today’s crash. In part this is true, for sure.

In fact, Windows and #Crowdstrike are centralized services, and many corporations, banks and so on use their services.

However, do you think that it so different than >80% of people running Bitcoin Core on their nodes? What would happen if Bitcoin Core had a super bug that crashed the entire system?

Of course, the network would not die, as not all the services in the world died today, since they run on other services.

It was not (only) the centralization, but the haste and the carelessness of the release that led to today’s event.

I think there is a huge lesson here, for us bitcoiners: think twice before updating your nodes, think twice when people try to push hasty updates to the Bitcoin code, think twice because bugs exist and can jeopardize the functioning of our beloved protocol.

Thank you for reading through my rant.

#UnpopularOpinion

#RandomThoughts

#Nostr

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Agreed!

Great note Fren, I believe you hit the nail on the head. We need to be slow and methodical about future Bitcoin core updates before deploying them to our nodes!

God bless 🙏 President Donald J Trump

#God #Trump #Prayer #USA #BTC #Zap⚡#Nostr #JulianAssangeIsFree 🔥🚀

What about Umbrel - It's an easy entry point for running a node, and a possible entry point for a widespread takedown of nodes ?

They shouldn’t do auto updates

This is the major diference. Afaik Bitcoin Core does not auto update.

That’s true. However, there are many plug-in nodes that are coming to the market. Do they auto-update, for instance? This could be a major problem.

I agree, they should not do auto-updates. However, we should be very focused on avoiding such things.

nostr:note199ftahnjzpxzamnv30uhv7t4jqs84fv9g7mfxlls35g3pszlzghq9zugtq