Nostr Web Client

nostr:npub10td4yrp6cl9kmjp9x5yd7r8pm96a5j07lk5mtj2kw39qf8frpt8qm9x2wl I'm testing NIP17 groups across web and 0xchat iOS. Nostrudel and Coracle both support and I'm using those.

NIP17 groups created on Coracle hold together on Nostrudel. But on 0xchat, they break apart into individual messages. Same for groups accessed on 2 0xchat apps and also the web. Withing the 0xchat world they stay together but then on the web clients they break apart into individual DMs. Maybe there are some slightly different interpretations of the group spec between 0xchat and Coracle/Nostrudel causing this?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

water783 3mo ago

Hmm, i will try to see what’s going on

JOE2o 3mo ago

Thanks. Also when I remove every relay of every type somehow I can still send NIP17 DMs.

And when I add just one relay of my own then DMs get sent but they don't show at all in that one relay's database.

I guess there is a DM relay hardcoded into the app and it always defaults to that one?

water783 3mo ago

In 0xchat, a NIP-17 DM will try to send to the recipient’s DM relay first. If none is available, it will try the inbox relay. If that also fails, the message won’t be sent.

JOE2o 3mo ago

Ah, got it, I thought it was similar to NIP4 DMs where it just goes to your write relays. Makes sense now.