i was being sarcastic and probably fiatjaf too sorry hehe. here is a fair criticism of NIP-29 but most of it has been addressed.
nostr:naddr1qvzqqqr4gupzp978pfzrv6n9xhq5tvenl9e74pklmskh4xw6vxxyp3j8qkke3cezqqxnzdenxgenzve4xyurgvfk9an8aq
Discussion
Ah thanks. Will read. I like it. It just works (mostly).
Yeah I think it's great if you are ok with the tradeoffs. Groups have different requirements than public posts.
Are there any other alternatives or attempts at NIP-29 besides his proposal?
there are other moderated community proposals but have been abandoned.
Yes, I'm building on a new one.
Community = Key Pair
1. It has its main relay + blossom server. But it can specify back-up relays and servers.
2. For Chat, users h-tag the pubkey of the community in their kind-9 messages
3. For all other content types users publish a separate replaceable event that lists the communities (not just one!) that are the target for this publication. If this event is 'found' on the community 👉 it's accepted there.
Etc...
I'm building a working implementation before doing all the PR and NIP-craft work.
Very open to discussions about all this 🤗