I only have a tiny setup at home. Its a nerdaxe. I tried with braiins and they paid out about 30 sats consistently a day. With Ocean I was getting more per block found, but they've recently increased their hash rate so now I'm getting about 30 sats per block.

Also when fees spike it changes the payout.

I haven't done any serious testing to see which one pays more. I kinda like the Ocean model and want them to get at least 1% of the hash rate. Thats why I'm mining with them instead of solo mining.

You can give it a go for a month and see which one pays more.