Nostr Web Client

Yeah, that's his point. You literally describe what "arbitrary" means to those two implementations. And arbitrary is literally when you do something by whim or impulse and not with necessity or priciple.

Writing "Nic sucks" on a dollar bill is arbitrary data that degrades the financial integrity of the bill and makes an arbitrary statement not for the purpose of a financial transaction. Writing that is leveraging the monetary value of the bill to force others to read your message. Do you see?

nicnym 9mo ago

No, I don't see the point which suggests you can *force* a bitcoin-core node to store (or look at) arbitrary data.

If you run bitcoin-core with default settings, you are opting to store all data that follows consensus. If you run knots then you and choosing to store data according to different rules.

The choice, and sovereignty is yours as the node runner.

I am not arguing against OGs like Mechanic in favor of arbitrary data.

I am pointing out that newbs might translate this as FUD that somehow core nodes are no longer sovereign.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

JackTheMimic 9mo ago

Maybe I am getting confused here but I read his post as the arbitrary data being accepted as valid transactions then validated by nodes. Core accepting these as valid, correct?

I think the operative word in his note was "Trying" to be a sovereign bitcoiner. Node runners aren't all availed of the knowledge that by running default setting of the MOST popular bitcoin program, they are to accept spam.

Sure we can say "Get good scrub," or we can chastise the spammers, which way Bitcoin man?

nicnym 9mo ago

Constructive education fostering conscious awareness to create more peers.