But what caused us to be hear in the first place? Something had to, right?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

*Here

You're talking about abiogenesis, or the initial spark that created life. Nobody knows, but the best explanation is amino acids and other primordial chemicals stewed in hot volcanic waters, and the strike of lighting at just the right place at just the right time initiated the more crude and rudimentary form of life. From that point, evolution explains how that initial lifeform became the vast array of life that currently populates the earth.

But what caused the chemicals for life to even exist? Nothing makes sense, it goes on forever. Even those dead set on a religion, sure God may have created to universe, but how did God even come about? He can't just all of a sudden exist can he? But it also makes no sense for things not to exist either.

Those chemicals exist as product of the creation of the planet. That goes back to the formation of the planet 4.5 billion years ago.

The religious people play an intellectually bankrupt game where everything must have a cause, except their god. It's how they get around holding their God to the same standards and reasoning that they hold everything else to. I don't buy any of that.

If you're talking about the universe, nobody knows what came before our expanding universe, or even if there was a "before", since time itself is a product of our universe and its unique rules. Maybe it's an endless cycle of expanding and contacting. Or maybe it's something else entirely. Quantum physists are pretty sure we are in one of many universes, each with its own rules. It's an interesting question, but not one we have a definitive answer to, yet.

Do you believe that everything that begins to exist has a cause?

I do not. That's the position of the creationists. I'm an agnostic atheist who doesn't believe in such a necessity.

I'm pretty sure that's just a fundamental point of logic, not something creationists invented. But I can understand your need to dismiss it to maintain your beliefs.