I think there are two benefits of having the kind of each list item upfront
1. it would make searches a lot more efficient for relays.
2. it would make it easier to decide how to render content for clients like Listr
Discussion
You guys are the experts, but I agree. It seems like there is something to be done here. Just my 2 sats.
I agree with 1 because there is no workaround to finding them other than fetching every kind 30001 and filtering and disagree with 2
I disagree with 2 because the list might claim it has kinds X, but it might not, so the client should not depend on what the list claim it has
But wrt #1; it’s essentially the same thing I proposed for the c tag for categories and there wasn’t a lot of buyin so 🤷♂️
I was thinking along the lines of a kind on each tag. Not at the top level of the list. Was that what you were imagining too?
Agree that you couldn’t really trust a list to always give you an accurate list of contained kinds.
a kind on each tag?? why?
no, I was just thinking literally a `k` tag so that I can do
`{"kinds": [30001], "#k": ["9802"]}`
to get a lists that claim to have 9802 kinds tagged
but now that I type it I don't like it and now I think I should just use a specific kind number for 9802 events (39802? 🤷♂️)