Shawl collars are for indoors. They're loungewear.
Discussion
I love them on my long sweaters and sweater dresses. They look nice. Down where I was born and bred, men wearing them are called bleeding heart liberals (not sayin’ it’s right…), the culture is brutal.
The liberal way to wear a shawl collar is to dress it up neatly. My advice is to go the other way: be haggard like a man at his cabin.
https://nostrcheck.me/media/public/nostrcheck.me_7385477656005412921695647845.webp
Yes, this is attractive. My tribe (again, not my opinion), casts a jaundiced eye upon such dapper duds. It’s sad that self-expression is so harshly judged. I didn’t own a pair of jeans my first two years in college and paid dearly for it.
This is the direction you want. Towards cabin wear with a workwear vibe.
https://nostrcheck.me/media/public/nostrcheck.me_3376479372968868941695647937.webp
Yes! Not fussy, not messy, well put together.
hilarious how things have flipped eh? I'd say this is now "far right"...