This exploit/bug with the Lightning network. WGMI?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

?

yeah, to me it smells like FUD hoax.

If I understand, both parties can boost fees spending the total, and making the whole transaction a donation to the miner.

Otherwise we could have a stuck transaction as fees jump away from the highest preset value?

It's fucking scary that one. But can't verify. Maybe it has less of an impact than it seems, I certainly hope so. Don't trust, verify.

Or maybe Don't panic, figure out the real impact first.

Yes.

A little ( maybe way )above my pay grade but I sort of get the gist. Just my short time using and running nodes many unexplained things happen. I just trust that the smart people are on top of it and we get there in the end. I accept we are early and take the risks to help the network grow and evolve. Doesn’t take away the nervousness of having a lot of corn on a node tho. Highlights that running nodes for everyday people is a ways off

nostr:npub15u3cqhx6vuj3rywg0ph5mfv009lxja6cyvqn2jagaydukq6zmjwqex05rq nostr:npub147wy3decmxy3vs9u4nse80ha7nkcydt7zdge8lc9gk8ddglh4t6qudjwdr nostr:npub1dmahfent0mtlh8ahhzu0ztslhw470azcyw3n599vvrxfysfg25mqurhrpq

Hard to find a “dumbed down enough” explanation of it 😂 Everything I’ve seen about it has been in very technical language. I’m curious to hear more devs speak into it so I can understand it better. Peter Todd posted this on Twitter saying it looks like a good solution but I would love to hear more opinions on it from those not in the “the sky is falling” crowd.

https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2023-October/022040.html

I’m looking for a better understanding as well, but I don’t think the sky is falling.

Even in the original post, the author stated that the theorized exploit has not ever been demonstrated in the wild, and it seems like you would need one of your channel partners to go out of their way to attempt this at significant risk to their own funds and reputation.

I’m confident that people smarter than me are working on a solution. Lightning still only makes up less than 0.1% of Bitcoin balances, so we’re very early in terms of potential severity. Even if the network needs to be entirely retooled from the base (which I doubt) I think that would be very feasible. If 10% of Bitcoin were locked in lightning channels, I might be a bit more concerned.