Wine might be handling auth differently than others, then.
Discussion
They were one of the first implementations, so they were winging it.
Any idea what the issue is? We updated it when they added CLOSED.
When a REQ is sent that requires AUTH and the connection isn’t authenticated, we send an AUTH challenge and a CLOSED with "auth-required: this relay only serves private notes to authenticated users"
I believe that is the expectation in NIP-42 - unless it changed again.
Nothing has changed, this is the correct way.
i think the problem has to do with a misunderstanding of client devs about how sockets work
the socket is a modal interface. it has a state, ready, and there are requests and responses... the way the nip-01 is written this categorization is not clear, so i can understand how this problem arose
it is very clear when you read the code that nostr:nprofile1qyd8wumn8ghj7mr0vd4kymmc9enxjct5dfskvtnrdakj7qg6waehxw309ac8junpd45kgtnxd9shg6npvchxxmmd9uq3kamnwvaz7tmjv4kxz7fwwajhxar9wfhxyarr9e3k7mf0qyfhwumn8ghj7am0wsh82arcduhx7mn99uqzqwlsccluhy6xxsr6l9a9uhhxf75g85g8a709tprjcn4e42h053vac7xr2j wrote for auth - a SOCKET is authed, not a REQUEST
if the client wants to make a request, and for example, the relay says it's "write-restricted" as in nip-11 (i need to add this to realy because i think this is relevant, write-restricted should also be part of the complex of elements in AUTH because what that means is "auth-required" to WRITE.
so i might go further to suggest that in the nip-42 text it should also mention that "restricted-writes" or whatever it is called, indicates that the sockets are modal upon AUTH, as in, when a socket demands AUTH it is because the request is "auth-required" which can be both read (req/count) and write (event)
I think this needs to also touch nip-11 and the "restricted_writes" field
auth required is ambiguous because it can mean both read and write
restricted_writes can be used instead of auth_required to signify that a socket doesn't need to auth to do read (req/count) but requires it for event
- auth_required should be specified to indicate for REQ/COUNT
- restricted_writes should be specified to indicate for EVENT
i am making an update to realy to match this clarification, and i hope there will be a revision to nip-42 to clarify the link to nip-11's limits fields and eliminating any confusion about whether NOTICE should be interpreted by clients
NOTICE is text to show in a relay log for clients. PERIOD.
i have realy send these notices because it is implied that if AUTH has been sent by the relay then AUTH must be sent by client or the socket is ded