Replying to Avatar MichaelJ

Has human-like intentionality in artificial systems been attempted?

I would argue that at least some part of the human will is a distinct nature, and not just an illusory emergent phenomenon. We can imitate much of it with complex decision trees, but I suspect there is some piece that is wholly irreducible.

In the realm of reason, we might call the irreducible component "insight," which is the process by which utterly new ideas come out of nowhere. I'm not sure we'll be able to give machines that same spark of insight.
Avatar
Low Information Voter 2y ago

Insight itself is largely illusion - some semi-autonomous modules of the human mind are capable of quite sophisticated goal directed planning and behaviour even when consciousness is directing attention elsewhere (or even asleep!).

The output - the insight - is experienced as coming "out of nowhere" by the consciously accessible parts of the human mind. But this is not irreducibly different in kind from a computer CPU experiencing an interrupt from a co-processor with a calculation to deliver.

Cognitive psychology is an Alice-in-Wonderland rabbit hole sometimes! I blame Sci-Hub for making the research so accessible :-p

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No replies yet.