Replying to Avatar Shevacai

The Daily Stoic - Meditations on Wisdom, Perseverance, and the Art of Living

Day 37

November 18th - Four Habits of the Stoic Mind

"Our rational nature moves freely forward in its impressions when it:

1) accepts nothing false or uncertain;

2) directs its impulses only to acts for the common good;

3) limits its desires and aversions only to what's in its own power;

4) embraces everything nature assigns it."

-Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, 8.7

From the Author:

"... let's align our minds along these four critical habits:

1. Accept only what is true.

2. Work for the common good.

3. Match our needs and wants with what is in our control.

4. Embrace what nature has in store for us."

Accepting only truth, or nothing uncertain, can be quite difficult without total knowledge, and in this day and age there are many things claimed to be true that are obfuscated, whether intentionally, or through lack of understanding/research. You must use critical thinking, as best you can, to determine if a claim is truth, or bad actors are attempting to lead you astray.

With misinformation being talked about by media, govt. officials and orgs, and people on social media, it's pretty clear that there is an agenda on who determines the truth. I think many could agree that those who claim for control over what we are fed as truth have something to hide. But that's not to say everything that is condemned by them /is/ truth. Use critical thinking.

Number three and four are very much about not striving for control outside and over that which cannot be in our control. Nature is as does. We can only accept what comes, and must not complain, lest we expend our energy complaining instead of using the momentum to steer in a direction that works for us, within our wants, needs, and abilities.

The first 2 don't resonate with me at all as a pleb. It makes a lot more sense from someone in a position of centralised power though.

1) accepts nothing false or uncertain;

2) directs its impulses only to acts for the common good;

Number 3 & 4 seems reasonable to me but again are probably more important for a ruler.

3) limits its desires and aversions only to what's in its own power;

4) embraces everything nature assigns it.

I try to remember that I ultimately know nothing & everything the universe throws at me is for a reason. When you're in a supreme position of power, you have a different set of challenges.

Interesting perspective.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Interesting perspective indeed.

I thought of 1 as "If you can't verify truth, then don't. Don't hold positions you're not sure about, but use discenment in how much energy you give to those things."

For example, I don't accept the 'facts' we're given on many things in the world, such that there are many differing angles that one can take. The current Israel/Palestine war is an example I can use. There are people making good and bad points on both sides, depending who they support. They say x, y and z about one or the other, and I'm generally uncertain about if it's the truth, or if it's embellished to some point to pull heartstrings. I don't know the history, motivations, instigators, etc, so I can't accept what people just say.

For the common good aspect of number 2, I think of that as centralized and very small scale, because those are things that are more within my power. My family is whom I direct my energy to for the common good. Generally it's being a supportive son, taking on physical burdens and helping with emotional/financial burdens. I believe that if I can help my family the best way I can, and then possibly my community, then it's for a common good. But I don't assume the common good in the sense that I don't push a direction of my prefered outcome, only support those in which I align with.

Both relate to me as a man with a centralized power over my actions and thoughts.

Yeah I'm more in the "I know nothing" & all i have is my strongly held opinions camp. It's probably not that dissimilar to your approach in practice, it's embracing the uncertainty & remaining flexible.

I'm also unapologetically selfish. I want a world where we don't have to fight each other & can exchange value & ideas. I want my family & the people around me to experience the abundance that's already available. Absolutely no altruism behind that intent though & i reject altruism in all its forms. I think altruism is an illusion & that you're better off being honest with yourself. I am always acting in my best interests & as a Bitcoiner, they're probably aligned with yours. 🧡🤙