Nothing you can't do with a regular API call. It sounds to me like using nostr for the sake of using nostr.

I don't believe this kind of messages should be part of the protocol, adding every single edge case to the protocol over complicates it, overcrows network and relays:ñ; and slowly makes our private keys a single point of failure.

I just implemented a wallet in Nostros by using lndhub API calls and I never had the need of using nostr.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

That's true for everything in Nostr. You can do all this without Nostr, in regular calls.

The goal of the NIP is to make sure Nostr clients don't need to understand the API of each LN connection type out there.

It significantly decreases implementation time. I added it yesterday to Amethyst in under 1 hour.

Cool

Wait, isn't it true that Nostr Connect is not required for anyone? i.e. all clients can go on with their lives without ever caring about Nostr Connect and still get the same experience?

Maybe I'm a nostalgic and I miss when the protocol was really simple 😛 you can basically run with only NIP-1, I'm just wondering if there is a point where it's just too much for relays to deal with everything at the same time, everywhere