Best I can do on short notice is color the scores the NYT "best books of the 21st century according to elites" list got. A score of less than 6 is either mixed morality or neutral all the way down to immoral or even evil. And that makes up pretty much 80% of the list. It tops out at around 8, and there are lots of very good books that sit above that rating, with ratings of 8 to 9.5.
And after I wrote that, I also took the top 100 goodreads books (which is slightly better than NYT), and a personal list I made of books I now plan on reading (and some I've already read). And the books that I've read that skew green/red do actually match my own experience with them, so I'm fairly confident in the results for books I haven't read.
**New York Times:**

**GoodReads**

**Personal**
