Nostr Web Client

pam 2y ago

I have a general question for anyone who has the answer :

1. Can all LNURL wallet support zaps or are there compatibility requirements if clients implement NIP57?

2. For LNURL, are the only 2 requirements LNURL Pay and LNURL Withdraw

3. LNURL Auth - If a wallet doesn't have this, does this mean it has KYC?

-----

Those that support : LNURL Pay & Withdraw

Alby

BlueWallet - Non Custodial

Bitcoin Beach Wallet - Custodial

Bitnob

Bottlepay

Breez Wallet - Non Custodial

Blixt

Lifpay

@Lightning TipBot

lnbits

Phoenix - Non Custodial

Simple Bitcoin Wallet (SBW) - Non Custodial

Sudonym - Non Custodial

ThunderHub

Wallet of Satoshi - Custodial

Zap Wallet

Zebedee - Custodial

Zeus - Non Custodial

(This list is from coincharge.io and thebitcoinmanual.com)

looping #[0] , #[1] , #[2] - if you have the answers, would very much appreciate knowing it

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Nathan Day 2y ago

The wallet provider also needs to implement NIP-57 for Zaps to work.

KYC requirements a function of regulations where the provider operates, not how the user logs in (LN Auth).

pam 2y ago

Thanks Nathan - if you are ok with follow up questions,

1) how to know which wallet has NIP 57?

I know WoS, Alby, Lightining TipBot, Zeus works based on users who have mentioned it on Nostr (i use the first 2) - how about the rest?

2) on LN Auth - so it determines custodial (3rd party with info) vs non-custodial ?

Nathan Day 2y ago

There's not a list of wallets that support Zaps that I know of. Eeasy enough to check, by seeing if a Zap works or is just a regular LN payment.

LN Auth can be done from either a custodial or self-custodial wallet. Its simply a way if linking an LN Wallet to a service, regardless of level of custodianship.

Make sense?

pam 2y ago

got it - on wallets supporting zap, i'm hoping to help ease up onboarding when new users ask abt this - so i probably go with suggesting what I know, works. on LN auth - understood on a surface level, which is good enough for now. I recall bluewallet removing custodial recently and its ability to link up to services (not their self custody wallet).

Thanks Nathan, I appreciate this !

Nathan Day 2y ago

Yeah, Blue removed custodial lightning as it was a regulatory liability for them. You can still connect it to other custodial services though or, even better, your own LN Node. 🤟

mykopikid 2y ago

I don't think Thunderhub support LNURL.

pam 2y ago

I got this this from here. Has it changed ?

https://coincharge.io/en/lnurl-for-lightning-wallets/

mykopikid 2y ago

Tried many times, does not work. But thunder hub can create and send to LN invoices. Cannot read LNURL-W or LNURL-P.